Brooklynian » Forum » Crown Heights and Prospect Lefferts Gardens »

Crown Heights North=Carroll Gardens II?

Share this!
 | 
    1. ilovefranklinave
      ilovefranklinave

      getting it
      Joined: Dec '08
      Posts: 78

      From the NYT: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/29/realestate/so-youre-priced-out-now-what.html?pagewanted=all

      My take:http://ilovefranklinave.blogspot.com/2012/01/crown-heights-carroll-gardens-part-ii.html

      Short version: Interesting comparison, interesting that the Grey Lady is making it. I do think it speaks to the fact that CHN is no longer considered some sort of fragmental extension of Prospect Heights by the real estate crowd, but is starting to get some credit for its unique charms and history.

      Thoughts?

    2. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      A lot of smart people purchased there in late 90s, and await cashing in their investments.

      I wish I had been one of them.

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    3. User has not uploaded an avatar
      Trumystic

      getting it
      Joined: Jan '11
      Posts: 104

      I think the NYT piece is crap. All the media on Prospect Heights ruined whatever character I loved about PH and I imagine the press and influx of annoying new people to CHN and who regard the Times as an authority will eventually do the same to this hood.

    4. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      That's a lot of power to give to a newspaper that is barely making ends meet due to declining readership and web viewers.

      ...if we are going to pick an arbitrary point that the neighborhood "began" to change, let's pick 1995. Let's then find a Nurse who saved her earnings to buy a brownstone, fixed it up with her husband and was a neighborhood bedrock during violent times.

      She, like thousands of others, is able to enjoy rising (or at least stable) property values, while her perhaps less savvy, perhaps less privileged, perhaps less hard working, perhaps less educated, perhaps more discriminated against, perhaps less lucky neighbors have their rents raised to levels that cause them to move elsewhere.

      The Times is a minor player.

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    5. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      PS. This guy believed in the neighborhood so much, that a few years ago, he bought a house just off Franklin Ave and then put lots of his own money into it.

      http://brooklynian.com/forum/crown-heights-and-prospect-lefferts-gardens/great-expectations#post-750285

      Do you think he will get close to his asking price of $1.1M?

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    6. eastbloc
      eastbloc

      comprador bourgeois
      Joined: Jul '09
      Posts: 901

      Let's not get carried away. He bought a house for a song ($250k or $275k if I recall correctly) and put just enough money into it that he'll walk away considerably richer even if it sells for a far more realistic price.

      Anyone who has $250k in cash and passes up a shell off Franklin Ave for that price is a moron. It doesn't take a whole lot of faith in the neighborhood to know you can't lose on that proposition.

      Now, if anyone _buys_ that place for anywhere _near_ ask, _that_ will be a definite sign of faith in the neighborhood

    7. eastbloc
      eastbloc

      comprador bourgeois
      Joined: Jul '09
      Posts: 901

      Trumystic said:
      I think the NYT piece is crap. All the media on Prospect Heights ruined whatever character I loved about PH and I imagine the press and influx of annoying new people to CHN and who regard the Times as an authority will eventually do the same to this hood.

      What do you regard as an authority?

    8. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      eastbloc said:
      Let's not get carried away. He bought a house for a song ($250k or $275k if I recall correctly) and put just enough money into it that he'll walk away considerably richer even if it sells for a far more realistic price.

      Anyone who has $250k in cash and passes up a shell off Franklin Ave for that price is a moron. It doesn't take a whole lot of faith in the neighborhood to know you can't lose on that proposition.

      Now, if anyone _buys_ that place for anywhere _near_ ask, _that_ will be a definite sign of faith in the neighborhood

      Eastbloc-
      I must confess if I had about 1M to spend, I would not be looking at the house I linked above. ...I would be looking at this one on Dean, near Bedford: http://realestate.nytimes.com/sales/detail/253-NS120113512/1142-Dean-St-BROOKLYN-NY-11216

      original wood details and genuine architecture, make me drool.

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    9. eastbloc
      eastbloc

      comprador bourgeois
      Joined: Jul '09
      Posts: 901

      You could probably have it for less than a million, considering it's been on the market for six months.

      That one might even qualify for a loan, and be quite affordable once you factor in the second unit's rent.

    10. eastbloc
      eastbloc

      comprador bourgeois
      Joined: Jul '09
      Posts: 901

      P.S. I suspect the problem with that house is that it's too close to the Armory -- if it was located closer to EP it wouldn't have much trouble selling.

    11. armchair_warrior
      armchair_warrior

      retsop cixelsyd
      Joined: Dec '05
      Posts: 7,946

      CH is too big for gentrifiers to make a dent in it. speculators still can make money if they buy super cheap sell at normal prices.

      Fight white guilt and injustice by smoking tax free guilt free Reservation Smokes or go gamble in a Native Casino.
      I like to stick it to The Man, The Man happens to be Liberal in NYC(power Structure).
    12. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      Lots of new condos and rentals have been built or renovated over the last decade or so, and many have been purchased by residents who are young, and purchasing or renting their first "real" apartments.

      The question that remains to be seen, is whether lots of "new" people with substantial assets will be attracted to the large, well maintained homes that exist in CH North. ....those that are currently selling these homes certainly hope so.

      Note, these big homes are not purchased predominantly by the young. ...I believe those who buy these homes are not looking to flip them; they are looking to spend the rest of their lives in them.

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    13. ntfool
      ntfool

      above average
      Joined: Sep '08
      Posts: 483

      This is true, from our perspective. Closing tomorrow on a brownstone in Bed-Stuy, have no intention of leaving anytime soon.

      If you're happy, you're not paying attention.

      spurn Productions, Inc.
    14. eastbloc
      eastbloc

      comprador bourgeois
      Joined: Jul '09
      Posts: 901

      Congrats. We did the same a few years back and fully intend to live here forever.

    15. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      Ditto.

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    16. ntfool
      ntfool

      above average
      Joined: Sep '08
      Posts: 483

      Thanks! And now I'm broke.

      If you're happy, you're not paying attention.

      spurn Productions, Inc.
    17. eastbloc
      eastbloc

      comprador bourgeois
      Joined: Jul '09
      Posts: 901

      You're not broke, you're house-poor. That's OK

    18. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      Ntfool-
      You know you have to continue to post even though you moved, right?

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    19. eastbloc
      eastbloc

      comprador bourgeois
      Joined: Jul '09
      Posts: 901

      The Times once again shows off their profoundly lazy journalism in an article on our 'hood:

      http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/01/nyregion/in-crown-heights-a-renaissance-with-unease.html

      Sounds like they took the train to Franklin, got on the wait list at Barboncino, interviewed three people for the article, had dinner, and went home, satisfied with the completeness of their knowledge of Crown Heights.

    20. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      The themes in the article are so familiar, she likely got her ideas from Brooklynian or I Love Franklin Avenue.

      While I'm glad the author finds these sites useful, to those of us that frequent these sites, the article merely reads like a summary of recent threads.

      By large measure, that it the purpose of the traditional media: Repackage what neighborhood busybodies know, into a format that is believed to be digestible to a larger audience.

      That is the job of the author, and she did it well.

      However, this is part of why I prefer my neighborhood news raw, and try to absorb news about neighborhoods that I am less familiar with, with similar suspicion.

      However, I did appreciate the quote:

      A corner grocery at Lincoln Place and Franklin where Ms. Williams shops, Bob and Betty’s, is now selling organic food, mostly to young newcomers, and giving away cardboard boxes to older residents moving out.

      The formula isn't complex:

      Neighborhood with declining crime
      + improving bars, restaurants, shopping
      + existing transportation
      + lots of rentals
      ____________________________________________________
      = newbies with money to spend will come in droves.

      Unfortunately, many newbies will then make the mistake (and implicit assumption) of publicly wondering "why didn't the people who lived before me want these things, and take care of their neighborhood?", and the old timers will seethe at the implicit insult.

      Sadly, many newbies fail to realize that even in the most troubled neighborhood's, most residents want better something better but have not had the power to exclude the negative elements.

      For the first time in a long time, this neighborhood now has that power. To the horror of those who have long wanted it, they will learn that this "new" power is very imprecise, and that no one actually controls it.

      ...and, as it always does, the beat will go on.

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    21. ilovefranklinave
      ilovefranklinave

      getting it
      Joined: Dec '08
      Posts: 78

      Here's my nitpicking take: http://ilovefranklinave.blogspot.com/2012/02/times-returns-franklin-back-in-news.html

      I thought the article was a decent summary (nothing whynot hasn't said a million times before, but hey, like he said, that's the biz), but I'm not sure using the riots as a frame made a ton of sense, except insofar as many of the NYT's readers only know of Crown Heights because of the riot. They also have a confusion juxtaposition of one riot photo from out near Utica with 8 photos from Franklin in their slideshow. Still, I don't think the riots are a major factor in what's happening now, or even in how locals (both new and old) think about what's happening now. To quote the great Kevin Phillip (as the NYT did): “I don’t think anybody really thinks about what happened here,” he said, referring to the riots. “It’s more what’s happening here.”

    22. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      I think the prior article in the Real Estate section reached far more people who have a potential influence over the neighborhood's direction than today's piece.

      A Sunday Real Estate section is read by a different group than the Wednesday Metro section....

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    23. vaportrail
      vaportrail

      getting it
      Joined: Oct '09
      Posts: 75

      haha. If the white population changed from 4% of the total population in 2000 to 19% in 2010, that's not a 15% increase. The author needs to take remedial math (as well as the fact checkers employed at the grey lady).

      in the thick of it
    24. booklaw
      booklaw

      admin
      Joined: Nov '07
      Posts: 2,399

      It's closer to a 500% increase, right?

    25. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      Brownstoner has a similar thread going and a commenter calculated the increase in white people to be around 358%, but who is counting? In many ways gentrification is just another word for Migration, which is pretty easily understood in terms of "Pushes and Pulls.

      While we can't expect an article to cover everything, the author also only focused on only on changes that are happening on and around Franklin Ave, when there are similar changes happening on Nostrand and eastward. Look closely, and you will see lots of black gentrifiers....

      Even more so than "Western CH", "Middle CH" has lovely, well cared for mansions on the streets around Nostrand. There are also well maintained rental apartments around New York Avenue.

      None of this is news developers or a flippers, that is where the real profits (and risks) are to be made. ...just look for the tell tale dumpsters on the streets.

      The real question is "How many people have been priced out of OTHER neighborhoods?"

      The answer to this question, coupled with things like how much violent crime we have this summer, will determine how much Western CH, and Middle CH changes in 2012.

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    26. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      Gothamist chimes in: http://gothamist.com/2012/02/01/crown_heights_gentrification_doesnt.php#photo-1

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    27. armchair_warrior
      armchair_warrior

      retsop cixelsyd
      Joined: Dec '05
      Posts: 7,946

      we'll see how it turns out in another 5 years. 10 years etc...

      As a long term investor. seems to be price in gentrification in many parts of CH. some prices of run down places cost almost much as PH run down places.

      Fight white guilt and injustice by smoking tax free guilt free Reservation Smokes or go gamble in a Native Casino.
      I like to stick it to The Man, The Man happens to be Liberal in NYC(power Structure).
    28. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      AW-
      I think a lot of young people are going to continue to have to rent apartments, as opposed to be willing/able to purchase them.

      So, think a strategy of buying run down tenements and then renovating them might be a safe bet.

      ....I'd also flip Single family brownstones, because a lot of the folks in their 50s are inheriting $ from their dying parents. Combined with the proceeds of a condo they bought in 1995, this inheritance is often enough for a brownstone.

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    29. armchair_warrior
      armchair_warrior

      retsop cixelsyd
      Joined: Dec '05
      Posts: 7,946

      :p i don't flip, i renovate and rent out :p. I put under use or not used at all houses back on the market.

      Fight white guilt and injustice by smoking tax free guilt free Reservation Smokes or go gamble in a Native Casino.
      I like to stick it to The Man, The Man happens to be Liberal in NYC(power Structure).
    30. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      I don't think I would have the patience to be a landlord in NYC; the laws are too pro tenant and Housing Court is too cumbersome.

      I'd flip, so I could take my profits and do progressively larger projects/buildings.

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    31. armchair_warrior
      armchair_warrior

      retsop cixelsyd
      Joined: Dec '05
      Posts: 7,946

      mines is really long term. But pain i the ass to borrow money with too many mortgages out vs income etc...

      really hard to convince banks to lend more.

      Fight white guilt and injustice by smoking tax free guilt free Reservation Smokes or go gamble in a Native Casino.
      I like to stick it to The Man, The Man happens to be Liberal in NYC(power Structure).
    32. armchair_warrior
      armchair_warrior

      retsop cixelsyd
      Joined: Dec '05
      Posts: 7,946

      also from what i learn, i won't get more than a 3 family ever again. if i sold now can't even get my money back LOL. apparently people don't like small buildings and banks won't lend on them vs houses.

      Fight white guilt and injustice by smoking tax free guilt free Reservation Smokes or go gamble in a Native Casino.
      I like to stick it to The Man, The Man happens to be Liberal in NYC(power Structure).
    33. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      But, no doubt, your unaware tenants and your family believes you are incredibly wealthy!

      Small business owners suffer the same fate: The have to constantly reinvest their earnings to keep up with the other businesses. It is Grow or Die.

      Meanwhile, those on the outside accuse them of being "greedy" or "exploiting" their poor customers/tenants.

      (and there is always some owner who is an actual greedy bastard that makes the hard working ones look bad)

      The fun never ends.

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    34. armchair_warrior
      armchair_warrior

      retsop cixelsyd
      Joined: Dec '05
      Posts: 7,946

      sadly my houses make the same money as the big building which i spent alot more on renovation and on the building and up keep and the house increase alot more in money vs not at all if i count the renovation money.

      I should of listen to people. who told me to convert it to like a 2 or 3 families back when I just first got it.

      Fight white guilt and injustice by smoking tax free guilt free Reservation Smokes or go gamble in a Native Casino.
      I like to stick it to The Man, The Man happens to be Liberal in NYC(power Structure).
    35. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      Possible consolation:

      Do your friends and family think you are successful?

      Do you enjoy the smell of drying plaster compound?

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    36. armchair_warrior
      armchair_warrior

      retsop cixelsyd
      Joined: Dec '05
      Posts: 7,946

      not really :p they know how much i sink into these projects.

      I enjoy designing things and fixing things.

      Fight white guilt and injustice by smoking tax free guilt free Reservation Smokes or go gamble in a Native Casino.
      I like to stick it to The Man, The Man happens to be Liberal in NYC(power Structure).
    37. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      armchair_warrior said:

      I enjoy designing things and fixing things.

      Excellent. We have found one reward. Other rewards could include:

      a. Always wearing clothes with paint on them.

      b. Having attractive tenants, that you like to talk to while you repair something.

      c. Having a favorite hardware store.

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    38. armchair_warrior
      armchair_warrior

      retsop cixelsyd
      Joined: Dec '05
      Posts: 7,946

      whynot_31 said:
      Excellent. We have found one reward. Other rewards could include:

      a. Always wearing clothes with paint on them.

      b. Having attractive tenants, that you like to talk to while you repair something.

      c. Having a favorite hardware store.

      all my clothes have paint and holes and black marks on them :p. lol

      Tenants hardly notice me :p i do stealth repairs.

      I goto many hardware stores. no favorite ones.

      Fight white guilt and injustice by smoking tax free guilt free Reservation Smokes or go gamble in a Native Casino.
      I like to stick it to The Man, The Man happens to be Liberal in NYC(power Structure).
    39. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      excellent!

      Let's also remember the joy that comes from dealing with the DOB, Housing Court and Sanitation!

      ....not everyone gets to read newspapers for hours on end, while they wait in a dirty lobby of a city office building!

      ...not everyone gets to try to prove they are not guilty of some petty violation, or gets to act like a mafia guy by slipping the inspector $100 to go away!

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.
    40. whynot_31
      whynot_31

      Former Lurker
      Joined: Mar '06
      Posts: 16,022

      eastbloc said:
      P.S. I suspect the problem with that house is that it's too close to the Armory -- if it was located closer to EP it wouldn't have much trouble selling.

      Regardless, this property has now sold.

      Selling price: 930k

      http://www.brownstoner.com/blog/2012/08/1142-dean-street-sells-for-930000/?stream=true

      For better or worse, the change on Nostrand is going to make the change on Franklin look minor.

    RSS feed for this topic

     Welcome! Please log in to post, or register a new account!

    Brooklynian » Neighborhood Message Boards » Crown Heights and Prospect Lefferts Gardens


    Members Online

    now :
    most recent : opossumqueen, newguy88, terekete, ninja, armchair_warrior, sytse, freehope36, howncreights, cool the kid, brooklynite03, ehgee, dac545, stewart, epiclylaterd, turtle95, landlord, mr. met, admin, cb123, xlizellx, crownheightsnewbie, veets, oscarin0, saintmarky, roux42, housebroken, ben