Brooklynian » Forum » Park Slope »

favorite restaurant in Park slope and why :)?

Share this!
 | 
    1. armchair_warrior
      armchair_warrior

      retsop cixelsyd
      Joined: Dec '05
      Posts: 7,947

      whats your favorite?
      Fight white guilt and injustice by smoking tax free guilt free Reservation Smokes or go gamble in a Native Casino.
      I like to stick it to The Man, The Man happens to be Liberal in NYC(power Structure).
    2. daniel
      daniel

      above average
      Joined: Jul '05
      Posts: 283

      LaVilla: pretty good standard Italian food. Big portions, everything is fresh.

      Kiku: Lots of vegetarian sushi options, much more than your standard cucumer/avocado rolls.

      Frannys: Best fancy pizza EVAR

      Mango: A step above your standard neighborhood Thai restsaurant, much better than Lemongrass.
    3. anonymous
      Anonymous

      rocking it
      Joined: Jan '05
      Posts: 16,296

      for upscale...applewood...hands down...excellent food at reasonable prices. in the city, this place would be 2 stars and the prices could be double. their sauteed lobster appetizer, their cheese plate, their meats are all fantastic.

      service is mixed...its friendly but not always professional. i like the wife and she is good but the other servers are mediocre. but the space is great and cozy.

      for casual, bonnies...good burgers and wings...casual and a good place to hang out. taro has excellent sushi at cheap prices, and stone park is always quality.
    4. User has not uploaded an avatar
      dw438

      above average
      Joined: Jan '06
      Posts: 514

      Subject: The best ....

      Is actually just below the Slope.

      Corner of 4th Avenue and 30th Street.

      Right next to the 72nd Precinct station house.

      WHITE CASTLE!
    5. whyfi
      WhyFi

      I'm Urban - recognize!
      Joined: Jul '05
      Posts: 5,268

      Subject: Re: The best ....

      dw438 » Is actually just below the Slope.

      Corner of 4th Avenue and 30th Street.

      Right next to the 72nd Precinct station house.

      WHITE CASTLE!

      One of my favs, too, but mine is 4-5 blocks away on Atlantic!
      ...not that there's anything wrong with that.
    6. User has not uploaded an avatar
      wally

      getting it
      Joined: Apr '06
      Posts: 84

      Subject: Rice.

      Rice Thai on 7th Ave.

      New College on corner of Union and 4th for a good (cheap) diner b-fast.
    7. idlewild
      Idlewild

      rocking it
      Joined: Sep '05
      Posts: 2,798

      Mr. Falafel. Tasty, simple food and inexpensive and the waitress' are babes.
      "Clamato! Straight Up! No chasah!
    8. friendlypitbull
      friendlypitbull

      above average
      Joined: Oct '05
      Posts: 261

      Song - very good food, very cheap
    9. User has not uploaded an avatar
      Diane

      getting it
      Joined: Nov '05
      Posts: 103

      Subject: fav. restaurant

      coco roco - consistently good.
    10. User has not uploaded an avatar
      parksloper

      what am I, new?
      Joined: Oct '06
      Posts: 2

      Subject: parksloper

      best diner in slope is still daisy's diner on 9th next to negards

      they were voted one of the best diners in brooklyn by daily news

      still its a diner but its great people best service . they are just the best... best breakfast there is and the best its open 24 hours and delivers 24 hours

      Rumor has it they will be offering kids eat free soon overheard manager talking to friend there on day

      breat idea for us parents
    11. gigi
      GiGi

      "drunk with honey"
      Joined: Aug '06
      Posts: 184

      La Taqueria.
    12. User has not uploaded an avatar
      The Chipster

      Irregular
      Joined: Oct '06
      Posts: 682

      Subject: best restaurants

      Rosewater: always fresh ingredients, inventive menu; great wine. Perfect for long lingering dates.

      THE NEW SANTO PALO!! (Palo Santo?) on Union btw 4th and 5th: GREAT lil plates, fresh herbs and homemade tortillas...cannot wait to go back. Fresh squeezed grapefruit juice every morn!!
      Ask a burning question, get a burning answer.
    13. User has not uploaded an avatar
      Anonymous



      Posts: 9,622

      So many good ones mentioned, but too many I haven't tried yet.

      I can't say these are my favorites, but I consistently like them:

      Press 195 - takes a long time to get the sandwich, but worth it

      Chip Shop for Mac-n-cheese (small portion) and a salad

      Number One Garden for fast, cheap and good Chinese food

      Blue Ribbon delicious, but not in my current (non) budget

      La Taqueria Nachos, baby, nachos.
    14. User has not uploaded an avatar
      femmedada

      getting it
      Joined: Oct '06
      Posts: 148

      Here are a couple that are on my short list:

      Night and Day--I love the jazz, the food and the late hours.

      Rosewater--the food is almost always excellent. I'm just glad that I didn't walk by the day that they were roasting a pig out front. Animal lover here!
      femmedada
    15. brooklynpotter
      brooklynpotter

      ceramme ceramma danna
      Joined: May '06
      Posts: 4,107

      clemens

      la taquiera

      bogota

      (are we noticing a trend here?)
      what would you tell me, if i could hear you speaking?--t.r.
    16. User has not uploaded an avatar
      mixergirl

      getting it
      Joined: Apr '06
      Posts: 181

      hands down Convivium Osteria--great service, great food, great ambiance.
      Sentiment without action is the ruin of the soul.
    17. Rosewater

      Blue Ribbon

      Nana for something cheerful and relatively cheap

      I've heard great things about Applewoods but not yet been there.
      Do you know where you're going to
      Do you like the things that life is showing you?


      Diana Ross
    18. linusvanpelt
      linusvanpelt

      Jockin my Mercedes
      Joined: Oct '05
      Posts: 394

      I don't know how I let this thread go by without plugging Convivium. Intimate, romantic (especially the cellar seating), excellent service, fantastic food especially the Portuguese-leaning stuff. I could go for a plate of their chicken livers with bacon right now.

      On the cheap / takeout side, Los Pollitos, no question.
    19. steve
      steve

      Cylon
      Joined: Nov '05
      Posts: 1,263

      where is convivium and what kind of menu do they have? I feel like I've seen it mentioned in passing 10 times now but have no real picture of it.
      For The Love Of Paris, Don't Go To The Lounge!
    20. linusvanpelt
      linusvanpelt

      Jockin my Mercedes
      Joined: Oct '05
      Posts: 394

      Subject: convivium osteria

      steve » where is convivium and what kind of menu do they have? I feel like I've seen it mentioned in passing 10 times now but have no real picture of it.

      68 5th Avenue near St. Mark's. Signage is very inconspicuous so easy to miss. Menu is Mediterranean with an emphasis on Portuguese and (I think) Spanish influence, as well as Italian. (One of the owners is Portuguese and one Italian.)

      NY Times review:

      http://tinyurl.com/ylfzw9
    21. erikka
      erikka

      above average
      Joined: Sep '06
      Posts: 754

      I used to really like la taquiera but the service there has become so incompetant that it's not worth my time to go there anymore. Last time I was there I had to tell the guy the counter my order at least ten times--all while he helped everyone BUT me. I finally broke down and asked if he was going to make my burrito or if I should just go somewhere else. Food is not good enough to put up with that crap.
    22. drano
      Drano

      Meow Wars Veteran
      Joined: Jan '06
      Posts: 1,671

      mypasswordwontwork » I've heard great things about Applewoods but not yet been there.

      It's really good, and I'd recommend it.
    23. User has not uploaded an avatar
      miriam

      getting it
      Joined: Sep '06
      Posts: 50

      Rachel's on 5th Ave btw 7th and 8th Streets

      I love their buritos!

      Hunan Delight on 6th Ave/Union

      Love their vegie chicken and dried bean curd!

      These are about the only restaurants I can afford...
    24. 8thandprez
      8thandPrez

      Stroller Person
      Joined: Sep '05
      Posts: 1,274

      Al di la - their seasonal raviolis are sumptuous. Hands down the most romantic place to eat if it's snowing. Total bitch getting a table though.

      La Villa - I know, this place is so 2004. But I still love their free bread basket, organic baby green salad and quite good pizza. My version of comfort food.

      Blue Ribbon Sushi - great sushi, tempura to die for, and really sweet servers

      Christie's - deeeeelicious veggie pies and coco bread

      Hunan Delight - hands down the best Chinese in the Slope. No one does seitan better than this place.
    25. steve
      steve

      Cylon
      Joined: Nov '05
      Posts: 1,263

      Subject: Re: convivium osteria

      linusvanpelt » [quote="steve"]where is convivium and what kind of menu do they have? I feel like I've seen it mentioned in passing 10 times now but have no real picture of it.

      68 5th Avenue near St. Mark's. Signage is very inconspicuous so easy to miss. Menu is Mediterranean with an emphasis on Portuguese and (I think) Spanish influence, as well as Italian. (One of the owners is Portuguese and one Italian.)

      NY Times review:

      http://tinyurl.com/ylfzw9/quote

      Thanks Linus!
      For The Love Of Paris, Don't Go To The Lounge!
    26. steve
      steve

      Cylon
      Joined: Nov '05
      Posts: 1,263

      I feel like I've written this recently but...

      Blue Ribbon is excellent.

      Stone Park too, and Sette is becoming a favorite.

      Moutarde, but I haven't been there in a couple years

      12th St., because they have the hangar steak, possibly the most popular meal on this board.

      The Mexican place on 4th and Union and for that matter Los Dos Pollitos on 5th and Baltic maybe?

      OT, but did anyone notice that Night and Day is becoming a BBQ place? I thought they were doing ok, but I guess not so much.
      For The Love Of Paris, Don't Go To The Lounge!
    27. anonymous
      Anonymous

      rocking it
      Joined: Jan '05
      Posts: 16,296

      TARO SUSHI!!!

      have you had their eel? it's the best I've had in the US.
    28. massimo
      Massimo

      rookie newb
      Joined: Oct '06
      Posts: 15

      8thandPrez » Al di la - their seasonal raviolis are sumptuous. Hands down the most romantic place to eat if it's snowing. Total bitch getting a table though.

      True, especially since they don't take reservations (it's on 5th & Carroll, btw), but you can put down your name, go around the corner to their wine bar, and have a nice chat and a good selection, then go to dinner 45 minutes later...
      "Truth springs from argument amongst friends."
      -David Hume
    29. User has not uploaded an avatar
      Anonymous



      Posts: 9,622

      libraryanne » TARO SUSHI!!!

      have you had their eel? it's the best I've had in the US.

      You're singing Idlewild's Taro song!
    30. raw
      raw

      rocking it
      Joined: Jun '06
      Posts: 2,037

      mypasswordwontwork » Rosewater

      Blue Ribbon

      Nana for something cheerful and relatively cheap

      I've heard great things about Applewoods but not yet been there.

      Nana WAS my favorite until they served me shrimp soup with only ONE piece of shrimp.
      I blame such comments on beer.
      © karlthedruid 2007
    31. raw
      raw

      rocking it
      Joined: Jun '06
      Posts: 2,037

      Besides for Amin on 7th Avenue, I have a hard time not LOVING at least one menu option at ALL Park Slope-based restaurants I eat at. It's hard not gaining 50 pounds in this neighborhood!

      My dream is to sit down at one restaurant and have the waited deliver me my favorite items from several restaurants at once. The hodgepodge would include appetizers from Nana and Nepon, entrees from Blue Ribbon Sushi, some of that smashed red pepper crap they bring out with bread at Aunt Suzie’s, and dessert from Tasti Delight.
      I blame such comments on beer.
      © karlthedruid 2007
    32. brooklynpotter
      brooklynpotter

      ceramme ceramma danna
      Joined: May '06
      Posts: 4,107

      still, dim-sum brunch would be a welcome addition.

      as would a real deli.
      what would you tell me, if i could hear you speaking?--t.r.
    33. User has not uploaded an avatar
      J0518

      above average
      Joined: Oct '05
      Posts: 593

      when i've got a few extra bucks in my pocket: Blue Ribbon,Rose Water

      on more affordable nights: Song, Bogota, La Villa, Sette

      for takeout: Hunan Delight, Helios, La Taqueria (where the service is actually very good and the people really nice)

      and when its real late and i need dessert: The Chocolate Room
    34. anonymous
      Anonymous

      rocking it
      Joined: Jan '05
      Posts: 16,296

      Subject: La Villa?

      can someone please explain to me why La Villa is constantly crowded and busy when the quality of the food is on a par with an Olive Garden? I thought Brooklynites were relatively sophisticated foodies in general. The food at this place smacks of crappy Long Island italian--it's awful!! Does anyone know any really good Italian places in Park Slope? Sorry to sound so critical, but I've given it about 5 chances over the past year and a half, and it has greatly disappointed each and every time. AND I had to wait a minimum of 20 minutes to be seated in every single instance.
    35. theoryofpractice
      theoryofpractice

      and a cast of thousands
      Joined: Aug '06
      Posts: 230

      brooklynpotter » still, dim-sum brunch would be a welcome addition.

      as would a real deli.

      SO true.
    36. theoryofpractice
      theoryofpractice

      and a cast of thousands
      Joined: Aug '06
      Posts: 230

      Subject: Re: La Villa?

      italianfoodjunkie » can someone please explain to me why La Villa is constantly crowded and busy when the quality of the food is on a par with an Olive Garden? I thought Brooklynites were relatively sophisticated foodies in general. The food at this place smacks of crappy Long Island italian--it's awful!! Does anyone know any really good Italian places in Park Slope? Sorry to sound so critical, but I've given it about 5 chances over the past year and a half, and it has greatly disappointed each and every time. AND I had to wait a minimum of 20 minutes to be seated in every single instance.

      La Villa is not great, but it does have a few things going for it. It's kid friendly, spacious, and the pizza is better than most.

      FWIW I've never had to wait for a table there, but we mostly get take-out.
    37. carnivore
      Carnivore

      Brooklyn Snark
      Joined: Apr '05
      Posts: 14,021

      theoryofpractice » [quote="brooklynpotter"]still, dim-sum brunch would be a welcome addition.

      as would a real deli.

      SO true.[/quote]

      At least Park Slopers near the F have a short hop on the train to Katz's. We in Prospect Heights have no such luck!

      Mmmm...... Craving pastrami now.....
    38. brooklynpotter
      brooklynpotter

      ceramme ceramma danna
      Joined: May '06
      Posts: 4,107

      Carnivore » 

      At least Park Slopers near the F have a short hop on the train to Katz's. We in Prospect Heights have no such luck!

      Mmmm...... Craving pastrami now.....

      oh man, katz's is so gross. i mean really, really disgusting. how can you eat there? even the knishes are bad. how can you make a bad knish?

      and sadly, 2nd ave deli is now a bank.
      what would you tell me, if i could hear you speaking?--t.r.
    39. carnivore
      Carnivore

      Brooklyn Snark
      Joined: Apr '05
      Posts: 14,021

      brooklynpotter » oh man, katz's is so gross. i mean really, really disgusting. how can you eat there? even the knishes are bad. how can you make a bad knish?

      and sadly, 2nd ave deli is now a bank.

      The only think to get at Katz's is the pastrami, but the pastrami is better than anywhere else.
    40. brooklynpotter
      brooklynpotter

      ceramme ceramma danna
      Joined: May '06
      Posts: 4,107

      Carnivore » 

      The only think to get at Katz's is the pastrami, but the pastrami is better than anywhere else.

      but what's pastrami without a decent pickle? or decent mustard? or a bowl of soup to start?

      and every time i think of the place i think of... buy a salami for your boy in the army.
      what would you tell me, if i could hear you speaking?--t.r.
    41. steve
      steve

      Cylon
      Joined: Nov '05
      Posts: 1,263

      brooklynpotter » [quote="Carnivore"]

      The only think to get at Katz's is the pastrami, but the pastrami is better than anywhere else.

      but what's pastrami without a decent pickle? or decent mustard? or a bowl of soup to start?

      and every time i think of the place i think of... buy a salami for your boy in the army.[/quote]

      The pastrami is just fine and for that matter so it the tongue, pickles are great too, all on par with 2nd Avenue. However, the chopped liver at 2nd was unmatchable. It was also a much cooler space then Katz's. I hate that ticket thing.

      That said, I'm stopping by about 6 today.
      For The Love Of Paris, Don't Go To The Lounge!
    42. carnivore
      Carnivore

      Brooklyn Snark
      Joined: Apr '05
      Posts: 14,021

      I love that when Bill Clinton went there, he basically got... EVERYTHING! And ate it all.

      Which reminds me of when Bush the Elder was president. He went to Carnegie Deli when he was in NY and ordered a BALONEY SANDWICH ON WHITE BREAD WITH MAYO! When they interviewed the Carnegie Deli owner afterwards, he said, "What a weenie!"
    43. anonymous
      Anonymous

      rocking it
      Joined: Jan '05
      Posts: 16,296

      Subject: The soup shack!!

      The soup shack on NW side of 4th & 11th!!

      The place is literally a shack....Built out of 2x4's with no sign. It's actually a flower shop, but they have about 10 soups all year long and they're all $3.50 for a pint.

      Secondly, and this is even more awesome: They have the best tamales and horchata I have ever had. And that's saying something because I am from San Diego.

      It's owned by a sweet Argentinian guy and there are always a few little kids running around. You'll love it, I swear!!
    44. idlewild
      Idlewild

      rocking it
      Joined: Sep '05
      Posts: 2,798

      Carnivore » [quote="theoryofpractice"][quote="brooklynpotter"]still, dim-sum brunch would be a welcome addition.

      as would a real deli.

      SO true.[/quote]

      At least Park Slopers near the F have a short hop on the train to Katz's. We in Prospect Heights have no such luck!

      Mmmm...... Craving pastrami now.....[/quote]

      You need to try David's Brisket House on Nostrand and Herkimer. It gives Katz's a run for its money.
      "Clamato! Straight Up! No chasah!
    45. pitu
      pitu

      Fake Buddhist
      Joined: Jul '05
      Posts: 6,770

      Subject: Re: La Villa?

      italianfoodjunkie » can someone please explain to me why La Villa is constantly crowded and busy when the quality of the food is on a par with an Olive Garden?

      I've never eaten at Olive Garden, but the takeout pizza at La Villa is dandy. Their Speciale is just the thing after a long day doing whatever you're doing that makes it impossible to imagine cooking dinner.

      italianfoodjunkie » Does anyone know any really good Italian places in Park Slope?

      al di la

      that's why there's such a wait to get a table . . .
    46. anonymous
      Anonymous

      rocking it
      Joined: Jan '05
      Posts: 16,296

      Subject: Re: La Villa?

      italianfoodjunkie » can someone please explain to me why La Villa is constantly crowded and busy when the quality of the food is on a par with an Olive Garden? I thought Brooklynites were relatively sophisticated foodies in general. The food at this place smacks of crappy Long Island italian--it's awful!! Does anyone know any really good Italian places in Park Slope? Sorry to sound so critical, but I've given it about 5 chances over the past year and a half, and it has greatly disappointed each and every time. AND I had to wait a minimum of 20 minutes to be seated in every single instance.

      I thought I was alone in my feeling that La Villa belongs in a strip mall somewhere. I just have not liked the pizzas I have gotten there at all. Why doesn't someone open a decent pizza joint with reasonably priced pizzas--I know, I know Anthony's but I have found that place up and down and I get the sense they won't be around long.
    47. brooklynpotter
      brooklynpotter

      ceramme ceramma danna
      Joined: May '06
      Posts: 4,107

      maybe la villa's so popular because the owner is a cutie-pie.

      (that, and i think the food is yummy)
      what would you tell me, if i could hear you speaking?--t.r.
    48. rose
      Rose

      above average
      Joined: Nov '05
      Posts: 911

      Subject: Re: La Villa?

      kensingtonmom » 

      I thought I was alone in my feeling that La Villa belongs in a strip mall somewhere. I just have not liked the pizzas I have gotten there at all. Why doesn't someone open a decent pizza joint with reasonably priced pizzas--I know, I know Anthony's but I have found that place up and down and I get the sense they won't be around long.

      No, don't say that! I love Anthony's. Why do you think they won't be around long? I agree about La Villa, gross. I'd rather go to a Pizzeria Uno.

      I had dinner at Stone Park this weekend and was not impressed. The food was just okay, the service was just okay, the dining room was overly bright, my husband's entree was cold and clearly had been sitting for a while, my creme brulee was cold. And -- I hate to say this since I feel like I'm always defending the children of Park Slope on this board, but there was a young child in clunky shoes or maybe even tap shoes who was continuously running back and forth across the dining room and no one did a damn thing about it.
    49. linusvanpelt
      linusvanpelt

      Jockin my Mercedes
      Joined: Oct '05
      Posts: 394

      Subject: Re: La Villa?

      Rose » And -- I hate to say this since I feel like I'm always defending the children of Park Slope on this board, but there was a young child in clunky shoes or maybe even tap shoes who was continuously running back and forth across the dining room and no one did a damn thing about it.

      Yes, this parent (and Stone Park patron) agrees that is not cool.
    50. friendlypitbull
      friendlypitbull

      above average
      Joined: Oct '05
      Posts: 261

      I really dont know where you anti-La Villa people eat 'regular' italian food (when your talking gross in the genre - Aunt Suzies jumps out to me)

      ; but in my opinion La Villa is the best around and every time I bring friends or relatives (or order in) they express the same sentiment.

      Besides the food, the service is friendly and good, the place is immaculate, and it is just noisy enough to make it good for kids but not so noisy as to be unplesant.

    RSS feed for this topic

     Welcome! Please log in to post, or register a new account!

    Brooklynian » Neighborhood Message Boards » Park Slope


    Members Online

    now : newguy88, msboombastic, pragmaticguy, nothinlikeabklyngirl, bobmarvin, juliafitz
    most recent : newguy88, msboombastic, pragmaticguy, nothinlikeabklyngirl, bobmarvin, juliafitz, laddhalsey, samuelcole, dac545, amighty, yuppie_scum, threecee, ribbons, el syd, stewart, back to brooklyn, housebroken, thecameralady, mishaps, tsarina, vick5y, reader, ntfool, bklyn.x, terekete, tateinbk, patsy miele kirk, sunshine11228, chelita83, eastbloc, epiclylaterd, admin, etccdb, ringrunner, yannis188, eastofmyrtle, foolio, walkathon, supreme_ian, xlizellx, ltjbukem, notsayin, plaza dude