This site is closed to new comments and posts.

Notice: This site uses cookies to function.
If you are not comfortable with cookies then please don't browse this website.

rental prices dropping? — Brooklynian

rental prices dropping?

tortuga
edited November -1 in Prospect Heights
hey all, a survey question of sorts. Does anyone have any evidence (anecdotal or otherwise) that rental prices are coming down in PS/PH? How about other neighborhoods (CH, PLG, Bed-Stuy, Kensington)? Are landlords willing to negotiate reductions (either at the end of a lease term or when signing for the first time)? Does anyone recall any sustained period of lowered rents in the past?

I'm just curious whether the rental market will track down with the buying market, or if they work against each other (e.g. the unavailability of mortgages increases the pool of renters, thus driving prices up.)

I don't know enough about economics to know whether the economy will effect rents or not.

Thoughts?
«134

Comments

  • Is there any evidence of properties going down in price significantly? I am looking for a place now, and at least in the Jweish Hospital complex prices are def. on the up and up w/no decline in sight.
  • When I was looking at apartments at the end of September a lot of places we looked at said that they had recently dropped the rents. Probably about 1/4 of the places overall mentioned lowered rents.
  • I spoke to my tenant recently about possibly raising the rent because of enormous heat and water bills. We came up with a plan that they would use their electric heater more and I would only need to put the heat on when its really cold out and so there was no need for an increase. Also I don't charge them a lot of rent because I don't want to be a hands on landlord, i.e., painting, I will purchase paint but you will paint yourselves, they are responsible for putting your own garbage out, etc.

    Maybe you can talk to your future/possible landlord and work something out along similar lines? I think its easier to do when you rent in a 2 family home as opposed to a multi-family dwelling or apartment building.
  • I left an apartment in northern Bed-Stuy and the landlord definitely raised the rent for the next tenants.

    Also, friends looked in the building I am in now a year ago and the rent has definitely gone up for us. Sigh.
  • I don't see any real decline in 1 bedroom apartments for sale. Price might be down a bit if you're buying a brownstone.
  • So I was just looking at one-bedroom prices and I noticed the funniest thing: on a couple listings in the New York Times, the stated rent would say one thing, like $1,700 a month, and then the listing on the brokers website would be about $50 a month less.

    I think rents are dropping.

    Now I don't think that will people that already live in rent stabilized housing with rents that are below market... That's because all you can do to protest a rent hike is leave, and you probably won't do that if your rents are less than the market rents...
  • unfortunately I don't find rents in the area's you mentioned going down. Simply because of the demand for those area's. It might not be the case in other area's of Brooklyn, but PS/PH have shown reziliance in the rental market. Additiionaly, the cost of monthly maintanace has gone up for the landlords. Heating, water and sewer, and taxes all have gone up a great deal.
    The cost to buy however, did go down. I believe it went down around 10%.
  • The area's you mentioned are in high demand. The last time I placed an apartment for rent in park slope, I had a flood of people coming in to see it. This was about 6 months ago. My apartments are usualy no more then 2 days in the market, if the next apartment will stay on the market for more then 2 weeks ...then ill suspect that the demand is slowing.

    It was such a big ordeal that I decided to give the apartments to real estate agents instead.

    You can take steps to lower the rent. negotiate with the landlord or even suggest to keep the hallways clean for a reduction in rent.
  • Rental prices in PH have gone way up the past couple of years and I don't think they're going to soften. There's an inverse relationship between buying and rental prices.....it's harder to buy now, so there's more demand than ever for rentals.
  • streeteasy has a load of apartments in brooklyn with decreases.
  • rents are only dropping if they're at the high end of the spectrum. $1800, I found, was too high to rent a 1 br, but $1600 is fine. too bad for me: now I'm selling. sale prices haven't dropped, even if you need to put between 35-50% down to acquire a mortgage these days. this is a high-demand area with very little inventory.
  • theres a studio on underhill thats been on the market for awhile thats dropped from 219k to 189k. Along with that theres been quite a few large price decreases.

    just an example..
    http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/154319-coop-60-plaza-street-east-prospect-heights-brooklyn
  • Bricktop wrote: Rental prices in PH have gone way up the past couple of years and I don't think they're going to soften. There's an inverse relationship between buying and rental prices.....it's harder to buy now, so there's more demand than ever for rentals.
    Prices for rentals are going down, smiple because the houses that aren't being sold are now being rented. This put alot more space for rent on the market.
  • I sure as hell hope that rental prices drop - I need to find a new place by Feb 1st, and I need a 2BR for $1800 or lower. Ha. Ha. Ha. Whee.
  • meganlibrarian wrote: I sure as hell hope that rental prices drop - I need to find a new place by Feb 1st, and I need a 2BR for $1800 or lower. Ha. Ha. Ha. Whee.
    good luck!
  • meganlibrarian wrote: I sure as hell hope that rental prices drop - I need to find a new place by Feb 1st, and I need a 2BR for $1800 or lower. Ha. Ha. Ha. Whee.
    Bayridge, has 3 bedrooms for that price and a driveway.
  • worldwide trader wrote: [quote=meganlibrarian]I sure as hell hope that rental prices drop - I need to find a new place by Feb 1st, and I need a 2BR for $1800 or lower. Ha. Ha. Ha. Whee.
    Bayridge, has 3 bedrooms for that price and a driveway.

    I also need to be on the 2/3/B/G for my daughter's daycare, which puts a crimp on things a bit.
  • OP here. Thanks for all the replies, just curious to see what people are experiencing. I actually live in Prospect Lefferts Gardens, but I rented for years in PH and was curious how the neighborhood is faring through the downturn. meganlibrarian, I'd recommend looking in this neighborhood. It's only one stop down from PH on the Q/B, and you can easily find a nice 2br here for $1800 or less. It doesn't have the variety of restaurants as PH, but there are lots of young families, and the park, botanic garden and the train are right there.
  • I really dont think anything is looking good for nyc real estate. The huge price increase over the last five years was caused by a number of factors all of which have just shit the bed. So yeah 1800 2br in PH might happen.
  • craigslist turns up a very prompt "no" to your 1800 2br quest. what are some other options for apt searching? it looks like streeteasy is mostly high-end stuff.
  • There is a big gap between rents and home values. It used to be that a building would sell for 10 times the rent roll (if the building GROSSED 100k per year in rent then it would sell for 1 million).

    As property values shot up this gap between rent roll and asking price grew by a large margin. About 5 years ago they stopped selling based on rent roll all together. You would see a building sell for 2 million even though it generated only 80k per year in rent.

    Because of this huge gap something has to happen. Either rents will go up or house values will go down. tortuga is right in suspecting that rents will go down, however things have not turned out that way(so far). Rents seem to stay the same as home values go down.

    It never makes sense to pay a 5k/month mortgage if you can rent the place for 2k. In this market I would much rather rent then own.
  • Just wait... Hee Hee...
  • you get around

    oh and found this. not in PH but on 14th and 4th ave. not the greatest area but looks decent. 1800 2 bed which says its 1000 sqf.

    http://newyork.craigslist.org/brk/fee/917699053.html

    edit....

    http://newyork.craigslist.org/brk/fee/917237690.html

    $1800 2 bed on St. Marks and Underhill. There must be something wrong with it but who cares thats pretty cheap.

    jesus im going to move...

    http://newyork.craigslist.org/brk/abo/917730300.html
  • Santa wrote: I really dont think anything is looking good for nyc real estate. The huge price increase over the last five years was caused by a number of factors all of which have just shit the bed. So yeah 1800 2br in PH might happen.
    My favorite saying, and very apt.

    Inventory is rising, and will continue to rise. INventory and price (sales and rents) are inversely related.

    Expect rents to drop over the near term, at least throguh Q3 2009. The below chart is for manhattan, but increased inventory in Manhattan will only put more downward pressure on the Brooklyn market (which itself is experiencing increasing inventory, also).
  • I'd be concerned and a little surprised if rents fall much, because carrying costs are up despite temporary relief in the form of asset deflation and a short-term rally in the $US. If rents fall, prices must fall that much further to bring the cost of renting more in line with the cost of buying, especially in a market where credit is extremely scarce. Or to put it another way, if rents are falling, deflation is widespread and you probably have a bigger problem, like you are at substantially increased risk of losing part or all of the source of income you use to pay the rent, such as your job. And you are at greater risk of moving in somewhere for less rent only to find it has been foreclosed soon after and you're out on the street. So be careful what you wish for, renters.
  • I'm moving east, u go to like Rogers or Brooklyn Ave and u can get a huge 2BR for 1300
  • ^^ however losing your job and dealing with a landlord is much easier than losing your job and dealing with the bank.
  • Santa wrote: ^^ however losing your job and dealing with a landlord is much easier than losing your job and dealing with the bank.
    You owe the landlord a few dollars, you've got a problem. You owe the bank a million, the bank has a problem.
  • doctorj wrote: [quote=Santa]^^ however losing your job and dealing with a landlord is much easier than losing your job and dealing with the bank.
    You owe the landlord a few dollars, you've got a problem. You owe the bank a million, the bank has a problem.

    I owe the bank a buck fifty ... k. will they be forgiving if my broker fails me?

    oh

    missed my flight. lupita ran for her tiny life and caused a 40 minute chase around the apt. oh yes. cat is now trapped in the bathroom. silly girl.
Sign In or Register to comment.