This site is closed to new comments and posts.

Notice: This site uses cookies to function.
If you are not comfortable with cookies then please don't browse this website.

MERDE! — Brooklynian

MERDE!

First thing I did yesterday morning was to donate to Wyclef Jean's charity. Figured he was already on the ground there. Now this comes up.
http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/years/2010/0114102wyclef1.html

The BBB is also not recommending donations to Yele Haiti.

Comments

  • There was something about this on Gothamist yesterday.

    http://gothamist.com/2010/01/15/is_wyclefs_haiti_nonprofit_legit.php

    I didn't donate to his charity and that has nothing to do with the smoking guns findings. I'm one of those who tends to stick with orgs like The Red Cross and Doctors without Borders. Both of which have had some questionable dealings in the past, but I like that I can at least request my money be used toward a specific cause.
  • Sadly a familiar story about the haves in Haiti taking advantage of the have-nots.
  • This Gothamist comment is worth considering before folks go projecting a lotta bad things on an org that does good work:

    http://gothamist.com/2010/01/15/is_wyclefs_haiti_nonprofit_legit.php#comment-2446060
    jayclay wrote: The $62,000 was two different annual payments, so $31,200 per year -- $2600 per month -- for office space in Manhattan, with reception services provided. Not so outrageous; in fact it sounds like a pretty good deal.

    And $100,000 for a star to perform a concert? OK, he himself could write off the expenses as a donation, but at a closer look that's all they paid. There's nothing listed for, as examples, renting space or sound/lighting equipment, paying people to run it, etc. If Jean paid all of that out of the $100,000, again a pretty good deal.

    Really I don't see any evidence that they haven't "wisely managed" the money they've raised, only that they've been lax in filing their tax returns.
    So yeah, how 'bout them tax filings. Seems to me that's the one thing actually known (and not just imagined or projected) here.
  • I didn't like the idea of texting to donate money to an org that I have no idea about. At least with Docs w/o Borders, I know their mission and I think they do it pretty well and are useful in this situation. While obviously not perfect, I think large groups like Docs or Red Cross are vital to emergency situations--they have the infrastructure and knowledge of working in these situations. Smaller NGOs seem good for micro-loans and local programs for chagne.

    I have no idea what the Wyclef group does so sending money to the vague plea of "help Haiti" seems odd. I know people want to help and that was certainly an easy/efficient way of sending $.
  • Yeah, YELE is much smaller, definitely not among the first rounds of aid orgs that come to mind for the majority of folks in the US or elsewhere.

    Guess they got out in front with the easy text/donate idea (and all over the news shows and Twitter etc) before any of the big orgs had a chance to.

    I'm guessing the initial grass-roots , impulse-giving surge to orgs like YELE will give way to much larger volume donations to the bigger organizations once there's been enough time for those decisions and allocations to be made.

    Interesting once again to watch the power of micro-giving (as happened in the Obama campaign) and the immediate amplifier and networking effect of the Re-Tweet, especially where these small, easy, impulse-friendly amounts are concerned.
  • Rachel Maddow had Tracy Kidder on her show the other night. He recommends Partners In Health. Here's his NY Times piece on why. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/14/opinion/14kidder.html
    Here's a link to PIH>. http://www.standwithhaiti.org/haiti
Sign In or Register to comment.