Shooting on Franklin between President and Carroll streets
Comments
-
damn, that is cheap WCW.
but, yea, there are two parts to living in and "up and coming" neighborhood. Because (by many people's definitions of safe) CH is not yet ready:
1. Those who are young and looking for deals will tolerate it because it is better than some neighborhoods.
2. Once they are no longer as young and desperate for deals, those same people may leave. -
GardenGrassCrap wrote: I thought I liked this forum but it seems whenever there is a serious discussion it becomes a pissing contest. How long have you lived here bullshit, who is more real. We are talking about people getting shot by a gun, being sent to a hospital. It all seems so selfish when people discuss how THEY have seen the neighborhood change, how much their rent is/was - we should discuss logical, realistic ways to curb gun violence. I am not saying I have the answers but I get tired when people talk shit behind a computer screen
You're always free to skip posts you don't like.
People hiding behind computer screens being fucking assholes to each other does not help.
You also don't know what these posters do when they aren't on this site. Some of them refuse to waste their time typing away with complaints and opt to contact the appropriate authorities when it comes to having certain issues addressed. There isn't much any of us can do about the terrible job these parents are doing with their kids, but the complaints that have led to increased police presence along Franklin has helped. -
I don't care about what these people do when they are not here. Why would I care? I care about teens with access to guns. I only hope you care about this as well.
-
GardengrassCrap, the alternative is that we simply don't bother post about it....
http://www.brooklynian.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=46168
but I think most of us realize that whether or not we post about gunshots and crime really doesn't make much of a difference.
Some of us would feel (have felt...) the same degree of futility if/when we express ourselves in other forums (nieghborhood associations, etc).
This is a violent city. Some of us think it is getting better, and are going to stick it out for a while longer. Others have had enough, and are going to move ASAP.
How long someone has lived here does provide a prespective, but I don't think anyone claims it makes them an authority. Everyone has their own tolerence for violence around them; no one likes it around them.
...even if the neighborhood continues to improve, it will be decades before it returns to something like these old guys remember it: http://citynoise.org/article/2078 -
Ishtar wrote: I heard from people who live on that stretch that the shooting wasn't random at all.
Actually you're correct, sorry. By "random" I was thinking of the idea that a random person could be the accidental victim of supposedly targeted violence while walking down the street.
It sounds like the drive-bys of the late 80s all over again.
More to the point, a lot of people have worked hard to make CH a better place to live. This is a blow to their efforts. -
been here for 9 years on may 1st.
Franklin & EP has definitely gotten calmer in general-- at times it seems like NOTHING happens here, good or bad. Then shootings come along and... well, shit happens.
From what i see, these days there's very little random violence around here. Things were not the same in 2001 when we came home to a gunshot hole in our bedroom window, etc. The incidents that happen (and i'm thinking yesterday's shootings, the girls on lincoln last week, the guy on lincoln last year) are committed by folks who have a beef to settle, and clearly zero brains.
which is just awful. I mean... awful. it's like living in an episode of the Wire.
There's plenty of anti-social behavior, kids who are just plain hostile to the bodega and shop workers (look at the abuse the mexican guys take from snotnosed kids in Sal's), and franklin essentially becomes a junkfood-and-yelling emporium at 3pm every day. If you live near franklin, you definitely get an up-close view of the failure of the worst NYC schools and what questionable parenting leads to.
but that's the balance. The rent's cheap, the neighbors are nice, i get special-customer price on beer at the bodega, the subway's downstairs, we throw the best party of the year ever Labor Day, franklin park, the museum, chavellas, the park, and the botanic gardens are a 5 minute walk away... make of it what you want. -
yes, to put it in psychologist and sociology babble:
This is a neighborhood where all of the residents are not trapped in a cycle of violence; Most do not experience violence on a daily basis. Some, however, do experience violence on a daily basis; they see no way other than violence to solve conflicts.
...sadly, school shootings tend to add additional people to the cycle.
but, nope, I'm not moving anytime soon. -
whynot_31 wrote:
Well, let's be honest here- you don't really live on or near that corner...and you also live in the nicest, most high-end apt buildings on the Parkway, save for the Meyer nightmare. You're also an owner.
but, nope, I'm not moving anytime soon.
So, yea- I can see why you're not moving. -
Whatchuwant wrote: [quote=whynot_31]
Well, let's be honest here- you don't really live on or near that corner...and you also live in the nicest, most high-end apt buildings on the Parkway, save for the Meyer nightmare. You're also an owner.
but, nope, I'm not moving anytime soon.
So, yea- I can see why you're not moving.
shhh, but -yes- all true. Luck has been on my side.
See my comments above about the 'hood catering to those in transition?
I'm no longer in transition. If was 30 y/o and earning 40k, my circumstances would be vastly different, and I'd be forced to live in the "real crown heights" (for the record, I've never claimed to do so ...but I do get out very often).
yup, I've settled. yup, I've been fortunate enough to land in a different world than some people just a block away. As you point out, (let's ignore the silly Washington Ave border for a moment), one can be completely different area just a few blocks away. As I allude to, one can attend a violent school and live in a violent family and be a delinquent regardless of the neighborhood they land in.
http://www.survivorsoftorture.org/files/pdf/rasm-aber-bhana2004.pdf
http://www.keepingkidshealthy.org/topics/youth-violence-breaking-the-cycle/
I don't blame you (or anyone) for wanting to leave, or actually leaving. I get it, I just hope that what some derisively simplify under the red herring of the word "gentrification" continues to spread east.
I hope that police and city services will continue to improve, and that the stores continue to change their offerings to meet the new residents preferences
I remain optimistic....
and rambling off topic.
nothing has changed. -
whynot_31 wrote: As you point out, (let's ignore the silly Washington Ave border for a moment), one can be completely different area just a few blocks away.
This is actually my situation and why I don't get why people like Cool the Kid SEEM to label ALL of CH as some type of hell hole. I live at Carroll and Franklin. It's almost seems like a different neighborhood between Carroll and Empire than President and Eastern Parkway. It's fairly quiet. All of the break ins, muggings and various other things Cool the Kid talks about are pretty uncommon in this small area of CH. Even when you consider I live pretty close to Ebbitts(sp?) Field. -
Subject: shooting
Haunted by a record??? Are you serious? Any one, any age, who takes a gun and shoots people SHOULD be haunted by a record.
I know there are those who say that these people are targeting specific people, but who says they're a good shot??
And if they miss it could be you, your child or the guy standing next to you that gets hit.
And there was another shooting of 3 people in Crown Heights this morning.
I mean.... really. -
Subject: Re: shooting
dakotas way wrote: Haunted by a record??? Are you serious? Any one, any age, who takes a gun and shoots people SHOULD be haunted by a record.
Nobody's excusing that behavior, but rather making a comment on the larger issues at work. Namely that our system of crime and punishment in this country, especially of juveniles, is severely broken and counterproductive.
Recidivism rates are through the roof. Jailing a 16 year old does not make us safer. I just makes us feel good about ourselves. -
Subject: Re: shooting
Boygabriel wrote: Nobody's excusing that behavior, but rather making a comment on the larger issues at work. Namely that our system of crime and punishment in this country, especially of juveniles, is severely broken and counterproductive.
Exactly.
Recidivism rates are through the roof. Jailing a 16 year old does not make us safer. I just makes us feel good about ourselves.
If there really is an interest in breaking these cycles within families, the justice system needs to do a better job with these children. One step could be rehabilitation for juveniles as opposed to only looking for ways to punish them. -
Subject: Re: shooting
Boygabriel wrote: [quote=dakotas way]Haunted by a record??? Are you serious? Any one, any age, who takes a gun and shoots people SHOULD be haunted by a record.
Nobody's excusing that behavior, but rather making a comment on the larger issues at work. Namely that our system of crime and punishment in this country, especially of juveniles, is severely broken and counterproductive.
Recidivism rates are through the roof. Jailing a 16 year old does not make us safer. I just makes us feel good about ourselves.
Admittedly, it does make us safer from that particular 16 year old, at least for a little while. But, yea, it does nothing to break the larger cycle.
http://blog.reclaimingfutures.org/?q=juvenile-justice-reform-family-involvement-Vera-tool -
Subject: Re: shooting
whynot_31 wrote: Admittedly, it does make us safer from that particular 16 year old, at least for a little while. But, yea, it does nothing to break the larger cycle.
Missouri's approach:
http://blog.reclaimingfutures.org/?q=juvenile-justice-reform-family-involvement-Vera-tool
http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/missouris-juvenile-justice-system/story?id=8511600 -
Subject: Re: shooting
whynot_31 wrote: Admittedly, it does make us safer from that particular 16 year old, at least for a little while. But, yea, it does nothing to break the larger cycle.
Right, but a short term view is kind of pointless if in the long term, Suspect X will be more dangerous down the road.
Also, great link Ishtar. Exactly what I was getting at. -
I agree with changing the system completely. Jailing these kids won't make them behave better and usually gives them more of an education towards negative behavior learned while in jail. But if there isn't an understanding that there will be punishment for crimes like this, then what will be the deterrent?
You are absolutely correct , the system is broken.
And it is the parents that are the front line in teaching their children right from wrong. Not the teachers or outside forces. With that said, how do you think this chain of events can be broken if the parents don't step up to their responsiblilites?? -
dakotas way wrote: With that said, how do you think this chain of events can be broken if the parents don't step up to their responsiblilites??
I think that's one of the hardest questions America faces today, and one that we're not really dealing with as a nation. -
Agreed.
-
Boygabriel wrote: [quote=dakotas way]With that said, how do you think this chain of events can be broken if the parents don't step up to their responsiblilites??
I think that's one of the hardest questions America faces today, and one that we're not really dealing with as a nation.
sadly, blaming the parent (note, not "parents"), isn't particularly effective either.
For the most part (as we are all aware) the father is absent and the mother didn't learn many of the skills needed to successfully raise a non-violent, thinking youth. The neighborhood influences, school systems and job opportunities certainly don't help mom raise the child.
(yes, there are exceptions, where a kid from a good family and neighborhood becomes a menace, but we are talking generalities ...right? We can agree that I don't need cites to show that delinquents predominantly come from overwhelmed families, who lack basic resources such as education, job skills, good housing, financial and personal discipline.... right?)
We can blame them for having children they weren't equipped to raise, yada, yada, yada ...but as everyone is pointing out:
Like it or not, the kids are here, and those are their completely ineffective, disorganized parents.
The parents clearly don't have the resources to do the job before them.
Vera (linked above) has some good ideas, and organizations like Children's Village have been working on the problem for decades.....
http://childrensvillage.org/
but clearly, none of the agencies or think tanks have "the answer" yet. (we are a dumb society, but not a society soooo dumb that it will ignore a solution that works on 100% of the kids 100% of the time). No one answer will work.
This is an issue that won't be solved in our lifetimes.
P.S. In the '60, the buzzword solution was all about urban renewal.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slum_clearance
Nope, it didn't work either. It just displaced entire groups of people, as opposed to individuals (like our current prison efforts) -
Always the optimist:
Depressing as it is, a look back to the '80s and '90s will show we are actually making progress.
But, like you, I hope are not at the beginning of a brutally violent summer.
P.S. Back on topic. Here's more coverage of the shooting:
http://wcbstv.com/local/rooftop.gunman.crown.2.1618691.html -
whynot_31 wrote: P.S. In the '60, the buzzword solution was all about urban renewal. Nope, it didn't really work either.
Sure didn't and that's a topic I stay very far away from. It's extremely loaded and hindsight shows how misguided it was and actually contributed to the problems we have now. -
Subject: Re: shooting
Boygabriel wrote: ...the justice system needs to do a better job with these children. One step could be rehabilitation for juveniles as opposed to only looking for ways to punish them.
To be fair, it wouldn't be the "Justice" department anymore - it would be the "Let's Forcibly Remove Troublesome and Troubled Children and Teens from Homes and Re-train them to be Productive and Socially Responsible members of Society" department.
Rehabilitation is a nice word, but it isn't easy to do, or otherwise someone would've done it by now.
So, I'm all for the above, but let's call a spade a spade. The Justice dept is for hunting down and incarcerating knuckleheads who fire guns willy-nilly into crowds in broad daylight.
Yeah its a shame this kid's never heard a kind word from a loved one in his 13 years of life or that he's beaten w/ a belt every Sunday - but I nor my wife or kid or mom or any innocent just walking around trying to live their life needs to catch a bullet to the brain because he lacks coping skills.
And honestly, I can think of no other way to correct these kids other than heavy-handed methods. At best their caretakers are negligent and completely uninvolved in the kid's life - thus the acting out and truancy and gang memberships, teen-pregnancies,etc. OR the caretakers are actively engaged in keeping the kid fucked up - beatings, yellings, sex abuse, making the kids deal or steal to feed their "families", etc.
The kid's got to be pulled out of that environment. Training the kid's going to be hard enough, training the kid and his caretakers simultaneously is pretty much impossible.
And since most of these kids are poor and most of the poor people in this city are minorities - this magical agency is now pulling shit-tons of minority kids out of their homes. So that'll go over swell w/ the media and community groups.
I understand that frustrated people are calling for the govt or society to fix the problem of these broken, troublesome kids, but is society or the govt really the problem?
99% of whatever is at the cause of these kids fucking up is happening behind closed doors. What can I, as a member of the community, possibly do about what some shitheel, who I've never met, is doing to some unseen kid out of the public eye?
Howdy, Stranger!
Categories
- 40K All Categories
- 27.1K Neighborhoods
- 5.1K Crown Heights/Prospect Lefferts Gardens
- 7.1K Prospect Heights
- 2.3K Fort Greene, Clinton Hill, Bed-Stuy
- 8K Park Slope
- 549 Williamsburg, Greenpoint, Bushwick
- 442 Flatbush/Midwood/Ditmas Park
- 657 BoCoCa (Boerum Hill, Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens)
- 151 Red Hook
- 104 Gowanus
- 304 Bay Ridge/Bensonhurst
- 130 Coney Island, Brighton Beach, Sheepshead Bay
- 270 Brooklyn Heights, DUMBO and Downtown
- 598 Windsor Terrace / Kensington
- 673 Greenwood Heights and Sunset Park
- 749 Brooklyn and Beyond
- 6.3K Stuff
- 86 Brooklyn Back When
- 1.2K Brooklyn Pets
- 257 Brooklyn Kids
- 241 Brooklyn Eats
- 51 Brooklyn Booze
- 3.6K The Lounge / Random Stuff
- 611 Brooklyn Politics
- 122 Brooklyn Sports and Fitness
- 111 Brooklyn Photos
- 339 Site Issues
- 8 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- 6.2K Listings
- 1.1K APARTMENTS and REAL ESTATE
- 1.3K Sales Openings Events
- 2.3K The Classifieds





