Parking for Park Place btwn Franklin Classon
I don't drive here, but when my parents visit, or we have other out-of-town guests, sometimes they have the need to park on the street.
My question is this:
On Park Place between Franklin Ave. and Classon Ave. the sidewalk is raised above the street. This is so that the vehicles can drive under the elevated Franklin Avenue Shuttle train.
To get up to the sidewalk from the street, there are stairs cut into the side of the cement. These stairs are not painted yellow and there are no signs on the street regarding street parking around the stairs -- but some people on the street have taken to screaming at people parking on the street or leaving threatening notes on the windshield* about not parking in front of the stairs. According to these neighbors, parking in from of the stairs can result in a ticket. Is this true?
I can't seem to find anything about this in the NYC laws.... The stairs are not driveways. They are not at the corners/intersections/cross-walks, but rather in the middle of the street. They are not painted yellow. There are no signs posted.
My dad actually parked yesterday in front of the stairs, but left enough room that you could go up/down them and walk around the car to get out into the street -- and was still yelled at by 2 guys about it -- so it's not just that they were worried they couldn't get up the steps, but they seemed concerned for him getting ticketed. I've never seen anyone ticketed, but that doesn't mean it couldn't happen.
Anyone know anything? I'd hate for someone to visit and for me to tell them it's fine for them to park and then they get a ticket.
Thanks!!
-----
* by threatening, I mean the note on a car in front of my apartment literally said "DO NOT PARK IN FRONT OF STAIRS. MOVE CAR OR I WILL CALL POLICE OR SET YOUR CAR ON FIRE."
Comments
-
local, unwritten, block laws are often enforced more often, and more effectively than written down, official ones.
Take the note's advice: Park elsewhere
To do to otherwise might threaten the ego of the people writing the note and telling your Dad to park where.
...this may cause said person to damage your car, while the block audience watches and laughs, leading you to wish you got a ticket.
-
I mean, we have always tried our best, obviously, to not park in front of them -- but sometimes it is difficult. My question, though, is about ticketing. Is it actually a ticket-able offense?
...I know who wrote the note. I doubt people would agree with this person on my block except his 2 equally as crazy friends. So I'm not concerned about your last part there...
-
I know you can be ticketed for parking next to a cutout in the sidewalk where wheelchairs can pass from the street to the sidewalk, even when the cutout is midblock and no yellow paint or crosswalk appears. This seems quite similar, so I would not be surprised if it too were ticketable.
Why don't you ask 311?
-
Usually there's a DOT sign and/or markers on the street where the cut outs are for pedestrian crossings. An example would be on Sterling Pl. between Underhill & Plaza. The cutout on the north/west side of Sterling is indeed in the middle of the block, but is parallel with the corner of Plaza and is clearly marked as a legal crossing. Saying all this, I agree with Booklaw. Call 311 and/or DOT.
-
Common sense would suggest that you not park in front of a staircase. Think about who may need to use the stairs - People with luggage, strollers, packages, children, etc.
If people coming down the stairs fall, could they hurt themselves more if a car were parked at the bottom of the landing? Yes probably. -
You are not supposed to park in front of the stairs, because there is not other access to the sidewalk from the roadway in that area. Police will ticket on slow days (actually 2 out of 3 times you'll probably get away with it, but why risk it?)because the logic is that the small walkays at street level are not wide enough for pedestrians to safely traverse the area.
Think about it this way, when your parents reach the point of needing a cane or a walker to get around, do you want them to walk in the street until they can get back on the sidewalk? Its a pain in the neck when you are looking for parking, but blocking the stairs creates problems for everyone on the block who is bringing packages up from the street, getting elderly people or small children up to the sidewalk, or anyone else with mobility problems.
-
If there is no law against it, park your car wherever the hell you damn want. It's a spot, take it. It is a problem when a bunch of people on a block can dictate their own policies through bullying tactics. Just be prepare to be as violent, as angry and as reprehensible in that moment in order to defend your right not to be intimated. It doesn't make you like them, it makes you willingly to do what is needed to protect yourself and your rights. The problem is that the majority of average citizens would rather avoid the conflict, so they bow to the desires of people who are willing to exercise their might and then comfort themselves by telling themselves they are the bigger person. While in actuality, it only encourages these people to bully the next person who tries to park in the LEGAL SPOT.
Of course, take my advice with a grain of salt. I do not live on the block in question. If you believe if I was in the position I would not act this way and only feel this way because I do not have to make the decision myself, then move your car. But I say you did nothing wrong. -
sorta unrelated, in some hoods of brooklyn some jerks would use cones to hold spots for themsleves all day long and if anyone parks at those pots, they'll do stuff to them. when day if i ever become as old and cranky as them, i'll go and blow their houses up for being such douche bags.
-
Hooray, Armchair's back!
-
Slope1980 said:
If there is no law against it, park your car wherever the hell you damn want. It's a spot, take it. It is a problem when a bunch of people on a block can dictate their own policies through bullying tactics. Just be prepare to be as violent, as angry and as reprehensible in that moment in order to defend your right not to be intimated. It doesn't make you like them, it makes you willingly to do what is needed to protect yourself and your rights. The problem is that the majority of average citizens would rather avoid the conflict, so they bow to the desires of people who are willing to exercise their might and then comfort themselves by telling themselves they are the bigger person. While in actuality, it only encourages these people to bully the next person who tries to park in the LEGAL SPOT.
Of course, take my advice with a grain of salt. I do not live on the block in question. If you believe if I was in the position I would not act this way and only feel this way because I do not have to make the decision myself, then move your car. But I say you did nothing wrong.^^^^This is exactly what is wrong in NYC today. You would encourage someone to do something that inconviences (and potentially endangers) ALL of their neighbors simply because they can? What kind of person does this? The stairs are there for a reason. They were not put there as a decorative structure, they are the only way to get onto the sidewalk for about thirty feet.
Since you say you don't know the block, let me try and explain it to you. The street angles downward while the sidewalk continues at grade. For about thirty feet, there is parking with enough clearance for the car doors to be opened about a 18 inches and then there is a SOLID WALL. There isn't enough space to walk next to the cars, and there certainly isn't enough space for anyone to manuver pushing, pulling or carrying anything. For people parking in this area, those stairs are the only way to get onto the sidewalk. Your only other option is to walk in the street with traffic, until the street angles back up and returns to grade. Its the same way on both sides of the street.
And you are seriously telling someone unless their neighbors prove to them there is a law against it, its okay to force everyone else to deal?
-
There are a few sets of stairs on this block, but here's a picture I was able to quickly find of one of them:

Ultra Cool Source: http://www.forgotten-ny.com/SUBWAYS/Franklin Ave station/franklin.html
P.S. I think the point that Homeowner and I making is just because a "local expectation" isn't a law, doesn't mean it should not be followed.
For example, the expectation might make sense. (as it appears to in this case)
However, regardless of whether an expectation makes sense to you, not abiding by it may cause something bad to happen to you.
...there is also the matter of potentially getting a ticket, because a bored neighbor complained to a bored cop. Even though the spot is not marked as being "no parking", the bored cop may decide to giving you one, under the theory that you will probably just pay it rather than fight it in court. ...and it gave them something to do.
In summary: Whether it is legal or not, I continue to believe that parking in front of the aforementioned steps is bad form.
-
i'd just look up and down the block and see how other people do.
having only parked on that block 2 or 3 times i would venture to say that most people block the steps - at least when parking is tight. -
I would say that Slope1980 is absolutely correct in his assessment. I will also say that it's time for the DOT to rehab the sidewalks and stairwells and install a traffic light or two in the middle of the street, along with markers, so pedestrians can cross in the middle, safely.
-
^ ditto.
there may be 1 or 2 people who are legitimately elderly/disabled inconvenienced by it but i seriously doubt there is block-wide solidarity to stick up for them.
-
Violation code 67: Parking in front of a pedestrian ramp.
Carries a $165 fine in addition to being deemed an asshole by your neighbors.
Just be prepare to be as violent, as angry and as reprehensible in that moment in order to defend your right not to be intimated.
Glad you don't live on my block.
-
Those aren't ramps though. Maybe I'm nit picking but, I don't believe they qualify as any type of crosswalk either. Those stairs are certainly not wheelchair friendly, the people who could really benefit from a ramp,by any means. I haven't taken a close look at the block for a while, so maybe my point is for naught.
-
They count as ramps. It's illegal to park there. And it's an annoying, inconsiderate thing to do. You're obstructing access to the sidewalk.
The neighborhood has relatively ample parking. There's really no excuse.
-
man. ... this is not at all the kinds of responses I was expecting.
I whole-heartedly disagree with people saying it's a terrible thing to do. Firstly, it's done all the time - and if you park far enough away to open the car door to get out, you've parked far enough away for me to walk. That said, the only LEGAL time you should be using these stairs is when exiting your car. Meaning there's like a 1-in-3 chance you are the one parking in the stairs you plan to use. The stairs are spaced unevenly, and basically allow for a TON of empty spaces on a busy block if people didn't block the stairs. So, the only time it's an inconvenience is if you park your car, get out, and can't get up the closest stairs. Mind you, they're every 8-12 feet, so I'm unsure why walking a few feet is a big deal. And again, it's only for people exiting cars, not for people carrying groceries home, people crossing the street, people lugging heavy packages, etc. etc.
I'm going to call 311 and clear this up since the responses don't seem based on facts of the law but rather what I should do to not offend my insane downstairs neighbor and his two friends.
-
xlizelx, if it is any consolation, you should taken the comments of Forgotten NY I linked into account.
When the station was rebuilt, the street underneath it wasn't touched, so the 1905-era steps are crumbling away and their railings are in a rusty, collapsing condition. This is likely a small section of original railing.In other words, it is not like these stairs exist as a result of some thought out master plan to serve the current residents of the block. If they had lowered the sidewalk to the grade of the street, there would be (presto!) no need for stairs.
As a result of their being no rule that such zones by marked with official yellow paint, you find yourself in an ambiguous situation.
I doubt 311 will be able to help you.
-
I don't know how regularly this happens, but I've personally witnessed tickets being issued for parking in these spots.
-
Whynot - that Forgotten New York page is one of my favorites -- I remember finding it some 6 years ago and driving everyone I knew insane with pointless facts about my favorite subway train, the Franklin Avenue Shuttle. And the awesome brewery complex near Ebbot's Field.
-
It's perfectly legal to park there. Even if we consider these to be "pedestrian ramps" it is legal to park at pedestrian ramps that are mid block. It is even legal to park at pedestrian ramps where there is a T-intesection mid block. The only exception would be if DOT had signs posted at the location prohibiting parking such as those found on Austin St. in Forest Hills.
Police Officers and Traffic Agents who issue "pedestrian ramp" summonses for this have obviously not taken the time to learn the traffic rules that they are enforcing.
-
Interesting, and good to know. Thanks, and I withdraw my previous indignation

Howdy, Stranger!
Categories
- 40K All Categories
- 27.1K Neighborhoods
- 5.1K Crown Heights/Prospect Lefferts Gardens
- 7.1K Prospect Heights
- 2.3K Fort Greene, Clinton Hill, Bed-Stuy
- 8K Park Slope
- 549 Williamsburg, Greenpoint, Bushwick
- 442 Flatbush/Midwood/Ditmas Park
- 657 BoCoCa (Boerum Hill, Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens)
- 151 Red Hook
- 104 Gowanus
- 304 Bay Ridge/Bensonhurst
- 130 Coney Island, Brighton Beach, Sheepshead Bay
- 270 Brooklyn Heights, DUMBO and Downtown
- 598 Windsor Terrace / Kensington
- 673 Greenwood Heights and Sunset Park
- 749 Brooklyn and Beyond
- 6.3K Stuff
- 86 Brooklyn Back When
- 1.2K Brooklyn Pets
- 257 Brooklyn Kids
- 241 Brooklyn Eats
- 51 Brooklyn Booze
- 3.6K The Lounge / Random Stuff
- 611 Brooklyn Politics
- 122 Brooklyn Sports and Fitness
- 111 Brooklyn Photos
- 339 Site Issues
- 8 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- 6.2K Listings
- 1.1K APARTMENTS and REAL ESTATE
- 1.3K Sales Openings Events
- 2.3K The Classifieds








