Community Activism - we need it!!!
Crown Heights continues to change very quickly. Often times, especially lately, it can be hard to follow and understand all the changes that are occurring. As a community, we need to bind together to keep each other informed, and we need to take action to ensure that we have an active hand in guiding the changes that will impact our neighborhood and the people who live here.
LaunchPad believes:
• Our community is in need of responsible, objective, proactive representation.
• Our neighbors -- old and new -- should represent the needs and desires of our community.
• There should be a healthier balance of power in our community.
• People are more important than profits.
LaunchPad is interested in working with the community to develop a new "Community Activism" program. We'll have more information in the coming months. In the meantime, please contact us to express any thoughts, concerns, ideas, questions, or interest in participating: [email protected]
Here's an example of the kind of situation we'd like to avoid (also on facebook, feel free to share there):
LaunchPad recently learned that Stacey Sheffey, Vice President of the Crow Hill Community Association, is employed as a real estate agent at MySpace, the realty company located across the street from LaunchPad at 722 Franklin Avenue. MySpace is known to use unethical, unscrupulous, borderline illegal tactics to force out longtime residents of properties they acquire and/or manage. After removing longtime residents, they then charge MUCH higher rents to new residents. In past instances of these actions by MySpace, the Crow Hill Community Association decided not to intervene, despite many pleas from forced out residents and LaunchPad. As Vice President of CHCA, Ms Sheffey is well aware of ruthless actions taken by MySpace, including the harassment and displacement of 2 families with disabled children. Ms Sheffey has decided to team up with MySpace.
MySpace will soon be the new owner of the property located at 730 Franklin Avenue, the lot that housed a community garden until very recently. You can read more about the eviction of the community garden, including a few ironic quotes by Stacey Sheffey: http://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20120514/crown-heights/crown-heights-community-garden-be-razed-as-neighborhood-blooms
What does this mean? Some may see business as usual in the NYC real estate world. LaunchPad sees a severe conflict of interest. The Vice President of our neighborhood community association is an employee of the real estate company that is forcing longtime residents out of our community.
Please get involved to help steer changes you believe in.
Thank you.
Michael Kunitzky
Founder of LaunchPad
Comments
-
There were huge downpours a few weeks ago, and after one such downpour I walked by the flowerpots that frame the entrance to the church that resides beside Launchpad. It was late in the evening. I noticed that both pots were filled to the brim with water. the huge pots have no holes in the bottom, you see, so there is no drainage. I placed my bag down and carefully, and I tilted one of the pots to the side to allow the water to runoff. At the task's end, a hipster approached me from across the street. He was hanging out at the bar. He was friendly enough, and he asked me what was I doing, and I told him, and then he asked me WHY was I doing it. And I told him I did it because I live here, and, living in this space gives me a sense of propriety for its well being. That ownership as we know it is not only in title form, but, pardon the pun, it is also in deed. 'Your deeds ascribe to you your role in your community, your investment in your community and your sense of propriety for it.'
What the wanton buying and selling of property does is to disrupt this perspective -- and to render that perspective illusion at best, and expressing such an opinion a delusion. I own nothing.
The aggressive MySpace gobble-gobble ethos, the buying and cutting of living spaces into smaller and smaller spaces, the kicking out of tenants who helped to make this neighborhood what it is, all for the benefit of someone's bottomline -- it is disgusting and parasitic. And it will only get worse.
I feel ripped off. I feel as if something was stolen from me. What living amongst the MySpaces of the world has taught me is the cynical wisdom of well-placed urine, feng shui-ed shit and cannily abandoned trash. It keeps the parasites at bay. Already my rent has jumped 20 percent in two years. Food prices are as high here as they would be in best neighborhood in Manhattan, if not higher. The irony of ironies, I'm going to Park Slope to get a deal on food.
I think I'm going to boycott it all. Bodega coffee for me y'all.
-
Some will drop out and drink bodega coffee.
Others will rebel against the machine
Still others will take the following view:

Which should you do? How should we live our lives?
...the answer is: "It depends."
-
We are talking about real life situations and this dude is "droppin' knowledge" with dentist office aphorisms. What's next Whynot, a picture of a cat hanging from a branch with the words, 'Hang In there' underneath?
-
My second choice was those teamwork posters about Excellence.
But seriously, if you don't want Stacey to be VP again next year, vote her out. Only about thirty (30) people voted last year.
Or, start your own, more powerful, Community Association. It will have no official authority, just like CHCA.
I'm pretty sure she believes it is a thankless job, with few rewards. I know I would.
Pro-tip: If your mtg has cookies, it will often be better attended, and attract smarter people than theirs.
-
What, exactly, is the real-life situation here?
I have to say, I'm a little surprised at Mr. Kunitzky. I've always admired his contribution to the neighborhood, on the basis of which he struck me as a mature and reasonable individual with a generous heart. And here I see him making bold, pejorative and unsubstantiated claims about another member of the community.
Even if all of these claims are true (and no evidence has been presented to that effect) this sort of public acrimony and appeal to sentiment strikes me as at best an attempt to leverage a venue for the pursuance of a personal war. I really can't imagine it could have much to do with bettering the community.
-
Indeed.
CHCA's rebuttal can be found here: http://crowhillcommunity.org/2012/06/launchpadresponse/
If we are going to address the multitude of problems faced by the poor and those who are evicted, thinking people will want facts.
-
Eastbloc - thanks for your compliments, as well as your concerns. All the information in my post is accurate. I invite anyone to investigate the facts. I have no personal grievance with Stacey; in fact, I applaud many of her previous community contributions. The issue is the conflict of interest I expressed in my post, which is only one factor of a bigger concern regarding the shift of greedy power and the harm it causes. These are very complicated issues, they can often be confusing. I believe my post contains important information that people should be aware of, that's the reason I posted it. My intention is to help better the community, in whatever ways the community decides it wants/needs bettering. You are free to disagree with any of my opinions, intentions, or efforts. Thank you for sharing your perspective.
-
As you may be aware, women with disabled children are among those most frequently evicted, and a substantial part of New York City's Tier I and Tier II family shelter populations.
The most frequent reason for these evictions is that they are one of the poorest populations in NYC, and fall behind in their rent. Judges consistently side with the landlords in such situations, because the law is written in such a way that the poor become "a burden" on the public, as opposed to single entity (such as a private landlord, or a corporation like MySpace).
This is deemed as "fair", in large part because no one would rent to a family that they could not pursue eviction against in the event of nonpayment of rent.
Of course the real answer would be to increase the income of such families so they are not constantly in these situations. However, this has proven to be much easier said than done.
Assuming the evictions that upset you were done legally, how could we reduce the number of such instances in the future?
If the evictions were done illegally, please PM me. I know a number attorneys who are devoted to the law, and skilled at litigating both sides of tenant-landlord law, as well as some who only work on behalf of tenants.
-
alwayslookaround said:
The issue is the conflict of interest I expressed in my post, which is only one factor of a bigger concern regarding the shift of greedy power and the harm it causes.Everyone is greedy.
For example, tenants are angry about the record high rent hikes over the last 2 years. But I personally saw a decrease in rent in that area in 2009-2010. So over the long term there is a direction.
I would not be surprised if folks looking to oust Stacey would benefit materially or emotionally from her departure. How long has she been there? How long did it take before she was elected and this conflict was discovered? Who vets folks who get elected? Has she personally been involved in any unscrupulous deals?
The only way any real progress is going to be made is if everyone is on board. The issue of gentrification will never go away until all parties are aligned in interest- which will prove hard to do when landlords and real estate agents are deemed the enemy. They are trying to make a living just like anyone else.
-
As others have pointed out this is a deeply flawed way of going about a project of community-building, and I too find that it has made me weary of your motives and intentions.
By choosing to single out one employee at a company (who, by all accounts I can find, was a recent hire), when it sounds like your real problem is with the company itself (i.e. MySpace), you seem less interested in beginning a constructive process to tackle a problem that many new and long-time residents of Crown Heights have shared concerns about, and more interested in engaging in in-fighting with fellow members of the community. That not only makes you seem like a bit of a bully, it also seems deeply counterproductive.
In addition, it seems strange that you spoke directly to the MySpace owner, whose name you give in your Facebook post (https://www.facebook.com/notes/launchpad/community-activism/10150876913271709), but that you didn't speak to Stacy herself. It's equally concerning that, according to you, this MySpace owner admitted that he is attempting to use a member of a community association to further his company's goals, yet you didn't point him out in your initial post, instead you chose to single out a long-term resident of the neighborhood who was working with the community for years prior to affiliating with MySpace.
In other words, while you're intention seems to be to point out that something fishy is going on, you end up looking a little fishy because you've posted a lot of generalizations about what you perceive to be going on, but then are extremely specific about pointing the finger of blame at a single individual. I would hope that we all know better than to think that all of the different factors that play into gentrification can be heaped on any single individual. And, as others have indicated, I have to believe we all know that effective communities are not built by tearing apart the people within them.
You might want to take a step back from this for a moment and assess what you've accomplished up to this point with this tactic. I have a suspicion you're not getting the massive rally cry of support you hoped this post would elicit, largely because a lot of the people who would support you are put off by the aggressive and misguided nature of your post.
You might do better to look for examples of communities that are doing a good job of addressing the concerns you have, because the reality is that many organizations and communities have faced these issues in the past and still face them, and do so without disempowering and attacking individuals and organizations that give voice and assistance to those who are the most marginalized in our society.
Here are just a few of the organizations actively working on these issues in New York City today, many of which have been around for a few years (or decades):
http://www.urbanjustice.org/
http://crowhillcommunity.org/about/history/
http://www.righttothecity.org/
http://furee.org/
http://artsinbushwick.org/bos2012/about/
http://www.pisab.org/
Not to mention: http://crowhillcommunity.org/about/history/You would do better to engage with existing communities, particularly existing communities who are comprised of the people you seem to want to help, than to try to divide and alienate those who are a part of the one you're in.
-
Cool the Kid - nobody claimed all landlords and real estate agents are the enemy. There are definitely some very unethical ones, and I believe they should be called out when they do wrong, especially when they have a long history of doing wrong. That's the only way to inform/educate the public about the risks and harms of working with them, as well as to encourage the public to work with more ethical landlords and realtors. Remaining silent about known issues is irresponsible, it contributes to the problem.
If there is a real estate group that is known to be harmful to a community, and someone goes to work with them despite knowing about the harm they have caused, I believe that speaks for itself.
-
Alexis - your perspective is appreciated. Hopefully you are an active member of the community. If not, hopefully you'll become one. It would be great to see such positive sentiments reinforced with action. If you want to get involved, I encourage you (and everyone else) to look into these issues for yourself. Ask questions. Seek facts. Connect dots. Personally speaking, I spend the majority of my time and resources working with the community, in person. Not only have I checked facts, but I've been directly involved in the situations I posted about. Again, thank you for such thoughtful feedback, I hope it goes to use in the real world, rather than just remaining as text on a digital message board. The community needs people like you to get involved, in whatever way you feel is best.
-
As Bob Marley said, there is 'there's so much things to say right now...'
This is a PAINFUL situation. I cannot begin to tell you how this aches...
If Launch Pad is inaccurate in their allegations, it creates a sense of disenchantment about community involvement. If Launch Pad is accurate in their allegations, it still creates a sense of disenchantment about community involvement.
Essentially, the efforts of those who pulled hundreds of pounds and a countless number of garbage bags -- filled with every kind of filthy garbage imaginable -- was to better the land for sale. And to know that the buyer resides on the same block, and was always there, watching and waiting....
And, all of the proxies who chime in matter of factly (and dispassionately) about economics and gentrification see this scenario lacking a dimension: the third. They are not privvy to how MySpace goes around pressuring people to move out and to sell, and when they are successful they go into the properties and cut up the rooms, making two bedrooms into four.
They just nod their heads, say words with many syllables, and move one.
-
Could it be that we are privvy, but have different conclusions and reactions?
-
I think so, whynot. For instance, I was happy to lend a hand to the efforts to move the art installation out of the garden, without any consideration as to whether I agreed completely with the political motives of the installation or not.
In retrospect, I thought it was kind of funny, but I don't ascribe the sort of primacy to my convictions that might make it harder for me to help first and foremost and discuss what happened later -- preferably over a beer.
-
It is a rather short, typical story.
I hope we are able to think of additional topics. Otherwise, we will be bored after half a beer...
-
If I'm ever bored after half a beer, I order a second beer.
-
Even if the other people around me are boring, I find whatever I am talking about to be rivetting after about the 5th beer.
-
We haven't had nearly enough opportunity to review each other after five beers. I'll take the blame for that.
-
And for the record, I freakin' love MHA. He's got a lot of truth to tell to power.
The problem is, we ain't power. We're a lot closer to where he is. He thinks the boundaries have to do with race, where they have little to do with that at this point.
I'm not from this country. I share a lot of views with MHA. I've gotten my ass beat in middle school for questioning American views about imperialism, the Iraq war, the Bush intervention in Panama, you name it.
I don't really feel like a conquering hero. More like someone who's getting it in both ends: from the locals and the police alike.
-
I think a lot of people feel that way.
For example, depending upon my mood, when I am accused of being "the power" I either find it to be offensive or amusing.
Sometimes, I find it offensive AND amusing.
When I am feeling generous, I let harmless people think and act like I am The Power so they can feel they spoke truth to power.
...I was taught it is good to give people a sense of accomplishment and feelings of self determination.
-
Maybe it's just the dog, whynot, but I see you as the personification of Lieutenant Columbo

-
Every fictional character is based on someone who exists in real life.
-
Huh. I didn't realize you were old enough to be the basis for Columbo.
-
You may be being to literal.
-
I had a rather unpleasant experience with MySpace when I was looking for an apartment last year. I didn't trust how they did things, and in the end went with a different realtor that I have a lot more faith in.
Just a couple days ago I was speaking with someone who was talking about their own apartment search with MySpace. The realtor said there was nothing in the price range (A massive range). She showed my friend a number of awful apartments and then showed a big gorgeous one above the price limit stated and in absolute no-man's land. Even the realtor said when asked how to get there that the renter should buy a car.
It would be great to be invited to share these sorts of stories and all other ones about this group in a local community setting. However, I share a number of the same concerns alexisclements does about how this specific issue was raised. I get the sense that's it's not even about bad experiences with this group but a second motive.
-
tateinbk - That is exactly the point, there is no second motive. We all need our neighbors (like you) to share their stories about things that are happening in the neighborhood. Personally speaking, I think MySpace stories are ESPECIALLY important. If MySpace stories are the only ones that are shared, that would be a huge first step in helping to better inform our community, as well as to start creating some long-term sustainability for people who live here.
In the few days since I made the post above (via the LaunchPad account), many people have told me stories similar to yours. There are MANY sentiments of distrust and disappointment associated with MySpace interactions. The concerns I've heard span a wide range.
There are also a lot of concerns about the practices of local landlords who own larger apartment buildings, many of whom work closely with MySpace. Some landlords have filed incorrect rental values with city agencies, which affects rent stabilization rates. Some landlords have filed questionable exemptions to remove their property from rent stabilization restrictions. Some landlords are charging higher rents than allowed by rent stabilization restrictions.
There is a serious risk of our neighborhood/community being improperly controlled and altered by landlords and realtors who do not act legally and ethically, especially if/when they operate in concert with each other. The community members must bond together to inform each other about what is happening, and then work together to find remedies for the problems at hand.
Everyone is encouraged to get involved, to ask questions, to share facts, and to help find solutions. Encourage your neighbors to do the same.
To the smaller property owners out there who may not want to get involved because they want to see their property values continue to increase - your property values will still increase without the manipulation techniques that are being employed by some of the larger property owners and realtors. Sure, higher rents may have some impact on the value of our property. But a cohesive, caring, diverse, integrated community will have a much more significant impact on your property value.
-
alwayslookaround I cannot get on board with the amount of blame heaped onto the VP of CHCA. I don't actually see it as a conflict of interest to have a member, even of high standing, also be a realtor. Additionally, I can't find much energy to blame landlords, especially the smaller ones, for trying to get as much rent as possible, particularly in this economy. Besides, that is what all the tenant regulations are for.
I'm often surprised by how few tenants are aware of their rights. It would fall within community building to help others be aware of their rights certainly. If landlords then violate them, taking advantage of WhyNot's connections or suggestions would be community building. Helping tenants to access help counts. Heck, I think it would be really useful to compile a list of realtors that people do have good experiences with. Considering MySpace's offices being on Franklin Ave. makes me wish they were more ethical in their dealings. I think it would be good if there were a forum where the community could confront them, even if it's just a public lashing on LaunchPad's website for example. What I've seen from them has been ethically suspect, but not actually so illegal. Frankly, I don't see the best angle being reporting to CHCA or Tish James and expecting them to intervene. Publicly embarrass them and make clear that no one in the area will work with them while they act in such a manner. That has the better chance of working to change them. It has to be approached from a financial point.
Again, though, I think it's taking the wrong angle to plead some sort of conflict of interest with CHCA and will not bring the community together in a healthy way. I also think it's incredibly naive to ask or expect landlords to keep rents lower in order to maintain a diverse group of tenants. That is simply not how housing in the city has ever worked. Creating utopias are difficult. Aim smaller to begin with.
To finish with, is MySpace really any worse than Rapid Realty or even Lang? Or is it just that they reside within our community so they matter more?
-
with all the talk of MySpace, does someone have the owner's direct contact information? They bolted up an advertisement for their company on the facade of a landmark brownstone on my block, and they haven't responded to calls to their direct line asking to remove it. and no, there is no apartment for rent in that building. the sign has been up for over a year, and it is screwed into the second floor facade.
since the landmarks violation hasn't encouraged them to remove it, perhaps a phone call from a community member might. it's a really ugly sign, and pretty insulting to those of us who are trying to make the neighborhood nicer. if they are trying to get higher rents, this kind of crap isn't helping.
-
thelambchop,
Taking and posting a nice big fat picture of it here might be a good start.
Got one?
Howdy, Stranger!
Categories
- 40K All Categories
- 27.1K Neighborhoods
- 5.1K Crown Heights/Prospect Lefferts Gardens
- 7.1K Prospect Heights
- 2.3K Fort Greene, Clinton Hill, Bed-Stuy
- 8K Park Slope
- 549 Williamsburg, Greenpoint, Bushwick
- 442 Flatbush/Midwood/Ditmas Park
- 657 BoCoCa (Boerum Hill, Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens)
- 151 Red Hook
- 104 Gowanus
- 304 Bay Ridge/Bensonhurst
- 130 Coney Island, Brighton Beach, Sheepshead Bay
- 270 Brooklyn Heights, DUMBO and Downtown
- 598 Windsor Terrace / Kensington
- 673 Greenwood Heights and Sunset Park
- 749 Brooklyn and Beyond
- 6.3K Stuff
- 86 Brooklyn Back When
- 1.2K Brooklyn Pets
- 257 Brooklyn Kids
- 241 Brooklyn Eats
- 51 Brooklyn Booze
- 3.6K The Lounge / Random Stuff
- 611 Brooklyn Politics
- 122 Brooklyn Sports and Fitness
- 111 Brooklyn Photos
- 339 Site Issues
- 8 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- 6.2K Listings
- 1.1K APARTMENTS and REAL ESTATE
- 1.3K Sales Openings Events
- 2.3K The Classifieds







