Should the shrine at Nostrand and Park Place, R.I.P.?
Comments
-
The former version of western CH is disappearing because folks like you insist on tearing it down + painting it over (albeit through sly passive language- "the former version of western CH is rapidly disappearing"- says who?)
I would just leave the mural alone. Its existence is of no consequence to the "new" CH and it could continue to provide some much needed familiarity to the "old" CH.
-
I certainly agree that I (and folks like me) will be blamed if it disappears.
....whether anyone should be blamed, is a different matter entirely.
On the other hand, if it remains, the team being assembled will likely deserve the credit, yet won't seek it or receive it.
-
We, the recently arrived or of a different skin tone, always get blamed for everything. Really the people blaming us should blame themselves for being unable to accept change in the world.
-
Everyone blames everyone else for the problems of the world.
No one has an easy time accepting change that does not benefit them.
...but we really should focus on that wall.
-
newguy88 said:
We, the recently arrived or of a different skin tone, always get blamed for everything. Really the people blaming us should blame themselves for being unable to accept change in the world.Its not a matter of having different skin color as it is completely rejecting/disregarding/painting over the old character of the neighborhood. Id say the same to whynot if he were black. I left CH because where I was did not line up with what I wanted in a neighborhood... I didnt disregard the folks there and treat it like a blank canvas to be painted to my liking.
-
well if the canvas is worn and peeling and if the names of two homicide victims who happened to be Marines are so ungraciously placed behind an ice machine, and other names are repeatedly covered up with bags of garbage, then maybe something should be done.
-
CTK has enough sour grapes to start a whinery.
The "character of the neighborhood" has changed a dozen times over the last century and a half. No one has asked anyone's opinion about it before, not when farms were being turned into mansions for wealthy New York bankers and lawyers, not when immigrants started flooding in, not when in the 1970's after MLK was killed and it wasn't safe to be white in this neighborhood anymore and that section of the population largely moved to New Jersey and Long Island, nor in the 1980's when crack arrived.
There are only two groups of people for whom the neighborhood is not better now than it was in 1990: drug dealers, and those who can't afford it anymore. For the latter, I'm sorry, but it's a free country, and you can't stop people from freely buying and selling real estate, opening stores, or renovating spaces and raising rents. That's part of what makes this country great, and what makes New York City the vibrant, dynamic, and heterogeneous community that it is.
If you felt you represented the good "character of the neighborhood" that isn't here anymore, CTK, then maybe you shouldn't have left. You have no one to blame but yourself.
Meanwhile, everybody else can go and enjoy the parade.
-
Tsarina-
You seem to be making progress in researching all of the names on the wall. Can you give us a summary of what you have found so far?You are using a combination of google and memories of locals, right?
-
Well, It seems the names are all homicide victims. The Marines were murdered in North Carolina, but one of them lived in the neighborhood. Another was shot in a nightclub. My personal favorite is Damon Allen, a decorated sanitation worker who had rescued a girl thrown out of the window of a burning building, was shot in the head while protecting others at a birthday party. Shooter had strong armed a robbery and came back for retribution after he was chased and captured but got away.
-
I thought I would make readers aware of an effort in Brownsville to redefine that neighborhood:
Metro wrote: Brownsville is known as one of the city’s toughest areas when it comes to gun violence, but there are many in the neighborhood who are trying to change that. Just two days before 16-month-old Antiq Hennis was fatally shot, a group of young Brownsville residents were proudly unveiling a pristine mural they had spent the summer painting.
The mural, on the corner of Straus Street and Pitkin Avenue, is the result of a collaboration between several parties: a community mural organization called Groundswell; the Department of Transportation; the Pitkin Avenue Business Improvement District; Brownsville Community Justice Center; and an artist named Chris Soria and his assistant artist DonChristian Jones.
Photo of mural can be found by following link:
http://www.metro.us/newyork/news/local/2013/09/15/brownsville-youth-showcase-the-beauty-of-their-neighborhood/ -
....something to think about
-
WOW this was just posted to my FB page and I had to come read the comments and now speak because it's clear that a lot of you are just speaking to be heard. 1-The first person placed on that wall was my Lil brother Earl Richardson aka Too Sweet died in 1976. Yes a child that was at a back to school party up the block with me and the rest of us Adults that we gave for the children on the block. Just something to do instead of being in the street on a late summer night. Upon leaving the party he was gun down to find out it was the wrong person the shooter or shooters was looking for, another Lorraine young mother shoot down in front of her children by a jealous boyfriend that kill himself also, another Keith Richardson accidentally gun down by NYPD because they thought he had a gun (NOT), another Perry Pace DJ Doctor Blood died from CANCER, Evelen & Diane young ladies died from asthma attacks. The list goes on and on. Yes a lot of murders are from street violence but NONE!!!! Happened on Park Place between Nostrand and Rogers. We loved our own and protected our own. I thank God I'm an OG that lived there for 40 years. I moved out of state but sometimes visit and go to that wall and remember those there and good times. We played with each other, we party, laugh, cried and support and stood by each other. IF THE WALL STAYS OR GOES EVERYONE THERE WILL STILL LIVE IN OUR HEART. Time moves on and things changes. AS A REAL TRUE LIVING OG SPEAKING FOR THOSE ON THAT WALL THEY DON'T CARE EITHER WAY. THEY MADE THEIR MARK AND WILL ALWAYS LIVE IN OUR HEART!!! Note that it's not always gang related nor drug related. STOP PUTTING OR CHILDREN IN A BOX OF DESTRUCTION. IF I HAD TIME AND SPACE I WOULD POINT OUT SOME ON THAT WALL THAT HAD DEGREES, A FEW THAT WORKED FOR NYPD & KINGS COUNTY HOSPITAL. PLEASE LIKE SPIKE LEE SAID WAKE UP. WE KNOW THAT THE AREA HAS CHANGE AND PEOPLE MOVED. I DON'T SEE THE SHRINES COMING DOWN IN OTHER AREAS BUT IF IT HAS TO BE REMOVE MOVE IT. BUT DON'T REPLACE IT WITH SOMETHING THAT WILL OFFEND THE MEMORY OF THOSE THAT'S THERE.
-
Thank you for posting Wil2Wat and please accept my condolences on the loss of your brother.
-
I do wonder if anyone has contacted the landlord in response to this thread.I have not.
-
A community member writes (via the site contact form):"I am one of the Founder of this wall I would like to know what the problem of this wall got to do with the comments that are being posted some of the some the comments are negative. this Wall was created in !992 any there are any questions that anybody is posting about negativity I will answer these questions for you and yes I live on the BLOCK FOR over 20 years"
-
follow-up post from the community member:"why does it bother any body"
-
Have you let the landlord know that there are still people around who want the wall to remain?
-
An additional comment from the site's "Contact Us" box:"Hi, I'm a reporter at News 12 Brooklyn, and I'm doing a story on a protest that's taking place regarding a post in your blog. Community members in Crown Heights say they're outraged that the question"Should the shrine at Nostrand and Park Place, R.I.P.? is being posed.Do you have any response? Please email me at [email protected] [email protected]. Thanks you, Zak Sos News 12 Brooklyn Reporter"
-
-
I hope Zak Sos is given the time and resources necessary to report this story adequately. I have emailed Zak Sos to let him know that I would certainly meet with him, but I would want him to explore the central question ["Why do you ask if the shrine should RIP, if you don't want the shrine to go away?"] as part of a story that delicately and tactfully explained what methods mights work to preserve it, as well as replace it.
-
A little birdie has informed me:Due to this thread, residents of the community (including those who helped create the wall, those who knew those whose lives are commemorated) have realized that the wall is in danger as a result of its general state of disrepair and the neighborhood's rapid change.As a result, a conversation with the landlord occurred.The landlord agreed to let said members of the community refresh/repair/redesign the wall once the weather warms up.All are pleased at the outcome....watch this thread for details. See you in the Spring.
-
I love it!! Great work @whynot_31 for raising awareness.
-
This is great news. I'm so happy that it will get to stay.
-
-
The name of the wall's creator as well a bit about its history is mentioned here, in a book about community murals:
http://books.google.com/books?id=ZCPHxOxguMoC&pg=PA127&lpg=PA127&dq=nostrand+park+wall+rip+mural&source=bl&ots=TEhf8EJ3YP&sig=r4g6xDwS3oAgj6ihUVPJPaZN07Q&hl=en&sa=X&ei=yHA3U6nnFKmtsQT42oCoDQ&ved=0CCwQ6AEwAw -
The fact that Nostrand is landmarked adds an interesting wrinkle.I suppose someone could argue that the mural/shrine is covered by the landmarking, and that Landmarks gets to weigh in on its removal, preservation, or redesign.
-
I assume it was there before Nostrand was landmarked (and technically it is not "on" Nostrand but on Park) so it would be grandfathered in.
-
Yes, if Landmarks had the energy and resources, it is my impression that they could argue it is protected.
My question is "does this effect the efforts of the long term residents that this thread has reportedly spurned into organizing?"
Are they going to potentially be told that they must go before landmarks?
Or (as I hope), will they disregard any such obligations, and restore/replace it in a way that they desire?
....perhaps while eating hotdogs and burgers, and drinking refreshing beverages on a nice Saturday afternoon. -
-
Or (as I hope), will they disregard any such obligations, and restore/replace it in a way that they desire?
This is what I hope for!
....perhaps while eating hotdogs and burgers, and drinking refreshing beverages on a nice Saturday afternoon.
Howdy, Stranger!
Categories
- 40K All Categories
- 27.1K Neighborhoods
- 5.1K Crown Heights/Prospect Lefferts Gardens
- 7.1K Prospect Heights
- 2.3K Fort Greene, Clinton Hill, Bed-Stuy
- 8K Park Slope
- 549 Williamsburg, Greenpoint, Bushwick
- 442 Flatbush/Midwood/Ditmas Park
- 657 BoCoCa (Boerum Hill, Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens)
- 151 Red Hook
- 104 Gowanus
- 304 Bay Ridge/Bensonhurst
- 130 Coney Island, Brighton Beach, Sheepshead Bay
- 270 Brooklyn Heights, DUMBO and Downtown
- 598 Windsor Terrace / Kensington
- 673 Greenwood Heights and Sunset Park
- 749 Brooklyn and Beyond
- 6.3K Stuff
- 86 Brooklyn Back When
- 1.2K Brooklyn Pets
- 257 Brooklyn Kids
- 241 Brooklyn Eats
- 51 Brooklyn Booze
- 3.6K The Lounge / Random Stuff
- 611 Brooklyn Politics
- 122 Brooklyn Sports and Fitness
- 111 Brooklyn Photos
- 339 Site Issues
- 8 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- 6.2K Listings
- 1.1K APARTMENTS and REAL ESTATE
- 1.3K Sales Openings Events
- 2.3K The Classifieds








