Shooting last night: Hart St
http://www.gothamist.com/
1 block from my new apartment at 340 Hart St Brooklyn, NY | 7/16/2007 2:14 a.m.
Thoughts on safety in this area?
MOD NOTE: I have an icky housekeeping request.
Could you please include a location in the Subject -- we've got a lot of shooting threads going at the moment. (sigh)
I've edited your title.
1 block from my new apartment at 340 Hart St Brooklyn, NY | 7/16/2007 2:14 a.m.
Thoughts on safety in this area?
MOD NOTE: I have an icky housekeeping request.
Could you please include a location in the Subject -- we've got a lot of shooting threads going at the moment. (sigh)
I've edited your title.
Comments
-
Might not be all that safe. There was a shooting there last night.
-
Yeah as I said. Shooting there last night. But alas I am moving there anyway and hopefully it will be peaceful.
-
I havent heard good things about bed-stuy from the people I know who live there.
but im a small white kid so Im sure im just being irrational and most of them are from the suburbs so i wouldnt listen to them. -
Pursuant to local custom, random gunfire is permitted only after 2:00 a.m. Conduct yourself accordingly.
-
i think bed-stuy gets a bad, racially and class-motivated rap.
it's a family neighborhood with problems like any other neighborhood. it suffered as much of new york did since the 70s but i am still excited to live there. hopefully i can also get involved in community organizing and dialogue with neighbors about crimes such as shootings and muggings. -
frankly, in most cases a neighborhood is safe as long as you don't get caught in the crossfire. i live in what many considered a bad neighborhood. there are fights, there are gunshots ... but they don't involve me. i'd of course like the area to be safer for everyone, but for the time being i don't feel unsafe personally. so apply it to your situation, if you can live with it, you'll probably be fine.
-
Ditto Jimmy Legs.
I have lived in a lot of "bad neighborhoods" and now live in Bed Stuy, and yes. There are fights and gunshots in my neighborhood, and I don't feel personally threatened by this.
I think it's important to work to make the neighborhood safer for everyone. I report everything I see to police, call 311 about "quality of life" stuff, and am a good, watchful neighbor who comes out of my house when I hear a ruckus.
And I think it's important to keep my nose way far out of the stuff that gets you beaten up or shot. I don't deal drugs in my neighborhood, for instance. -
I been around that area.. It isn't as appealing as other parts of BedStuy due to constant noise and people hanging out..But I would say - you should be safe there.. Police are everywhere in BedStuy..There may be a police officer stationed 2 blocks away.. ( I recall, maybe) .. There are mandates that on certain blocks -- a police officer be present.. for public safety,etc..
-
Anonymous wrote:
Which neighborhood DO you deal drugs in?
And I think it's important to keep my nose way far out of the stuff that gets you beaten up or shot. I don't deal drugs in my neighborhood, for instance. -
I'm with the FDNY as an EMT. In the past I've encountered people who don't know what an EMT is. An EMT is an Emergency Medical Technician. What that means is that I work on an ambulance. So my office says "FDNY AMBULANCE" on it and it has wheels. Get it?
Ok- I have worked Bed Stuy for the past three years. I'm from Brooklyn. I was born in Bensonhurst and was a minority in the neighborhood because I'm Irish. What I'm driving at, if it matters, is that I am white.
I have seen a sense of community and family in Bed Stuy that I've never experienced in any neighborhood I've lived in or visited. I have seen families outside their buildings talking to one another, barbequeing together, etc. I've walked into apartments and houses and seen concerned neighbors who have called 911 because their elderly neighbor isn't feeling well. There is a strong sense of community.
I have also seen unspeakable violence which would send some people to therapists. I was the first unit on scene at the triple shooting on Gates Av outside the Louis Armstrong Houses Wednesday night. I transported the 16 year old that the paper listed as "critically injured". Trust me- he was critically injured. While I was treating him, I had two more people shot laying on the ground and begging me for help until other units showed up on scene. Today a kid sitting on Gates Avenue cursed at me and blamed me for what happened to his friend. I said "I didn't put the bullet in him, pal" and drove off.
My point is- this shooting took place outside of a housing project. Housing projects are for low income families. If you look at the American history of any ethnic group- the Italians, the Germans, the Irish, the Jews- I defy you to find a difference between them and the poverty stricken black families living in the projects in Bed Stuy. The Irish, the Germans, the Jews, the Italians- all of them at one time were considered violent and ignorant.
On certain blocks in Bed Stuy are brownstones more beautiful than any in the city. I have had the pleasure of being inside some of these homes and have spoken with the residents. In these buildings I have encountered intelligent, educated, polite, wonderful black men and women who want only to live amongst their own people. I understand this. When I was growing up, I wanted to live amongst Irish people. Water seeks it's own level. We all fundamentally want to live among people to which we can relate.
I do not wish to say that people who live in the projects are not as intelligent as those who own brownstones. I only mean to say that they are at a disadvantage and should be given some "slack", based on economic status and all that that implies.
The main thing I wish to say is this- As a white man, who does not consider himself to have any racial prejudices- I sit at work. I sit on Fulton and Nostrand. And I sit and watch black children, and black families, black men and women go about their business in their own neighborhood. And then every now and again- one of you midwestern born, white hipsters pops out from the subway stairs in your V-neck hanes t-shirt, your fedora, your beard and glasses, and your stupid fucking idealistic smile. And I say to myself "You know what- if this motherfucker moved into my neighborhood, I don't think I could stop myself from robbing him."
New York is a tough city, and Bed Stuy is quite possibly the strongest evidence this city has. If you ain't from there, don't go there. And don't cry to me when you get pistol whipped and all you money gets vicked. As far as I'm concerned, you asked for it.
To the real Bed Stuy community- I'm here to serve you. If you see us sitting in our ambulance (which may not be that often because we've been very very busy lately) wave at us. Come up and talk to us. We're on this job because we love people. I promise you, if you pick the ambulance with me and my partner inside, you'll leave laughing. We're here for you.
YUPPIES GO HOME -
so, by that logic, would you also post "BLACKS GO HOME" on a message board covering the upper east side?
-
ashlee spears wrote: so, by that logic, would you also post "BLACKS GO HOME" on a message board covering the upper east side?
Yeah, SevenAdam does really well until his last few paragraphs and then his sign-off shatters any remaining credibility he may have had.
Good effort but better luck next time. -
SevenAdam wrote: The main thing I wish to say is this- As a white man, who does not consider himself to have any racial prejudices- I sit at work. I sit on Fulton and Nostrand. And I sit and watch black children, and black families, black men and women go about their business in their own neighborhood. And then every now and again- one of you midwestern born, white hipsters pops out from the subway stairs in your V-neck hanes t-shirt, your fedora, your beard and glasses, and your stupid fucking idealistic smile. And I say to myself "You know what- if this motherfucker moved into my neighborhood, I don't think I could stop myself from robbing him."
The thing you forget, SevenAdam, is that years ago, when BedStuy was first predominantly white, someone had to be the first black person to move in. Would you have back then told them to "go home", knowing then what you know now?
New York is a tough city, and Bed Stuy is quite possibly the strongest evidence this city has. If you ain't from there, don't go there. And don't cry to me when you get pistol whipped and all you money gets vicked. As far as I'm concerned, you asked for it.
You have a point when you say that things are different for the people in the projects and in lower-income areas than they are for people in other areas, but you have mistaken race for CLASS. The "midwestern white face" you see may be someone who actually has moved there, not because they're trying to make it hip, but because they sincerely can't afford to live anywhere else. White people can be broke too, and can be genuinely interested in integrating into a community.
You claim to not be racist, but you have classified the people of one entire neighborhood by the color of their skin. You speak of yourself as the protector of the "real BedStuy," but something tells me that you've failed to notice that people of all colors live there.
I wonder whether you even see the people in the community you protect as people, rather than as "charges" you are trying to nobly protect. -
Ok- I see some valid responses to my post, I don't have time to address them at the moment- I'm on my way out the door. I will write back later. Again- valid points were made, and I would like to clarify what I was saying. I appreciate the intelligent dialogue instead of verbal assault. I mean that sincerely. I will write more later.
-
Personally, I'm really annoyed by what SevenAdam posted. I'm a young black male who recently moved to the area --- not from the city --- but from one of the whitest (demographically speaking) small towns in New York. I don't feel out of place at all and I don't dress like many of the people in the neighborhood. Ironically enough, I feel more at home here than the town I grew up in all of my life. I live by Franklin and Classon which is not Bed Stuy proper, but it's Bed Stuy enough. From what I've seen, the area I'm at is around 75% black, 25% white and everyone seems to coexist and even talk to one another. I've walked into Bed Stuy at night to Marcy Avenue to pick up my Asian friend (who, of course, sticks out like a sore thumb) at night and I've been fine. She does say that guys cat call the shit out of her when I'm not around, but she's never been robbed, mugged, raped, anything of the sort. But to address SevenAdam, If I didn't know better, I'd say that I am no different than that hypothetical white male he described. But who's to say that the white male is any different from any black person who lives in the neighborhood? SevenAdam seems like a white person who is trying too hard to sympathize with the black struggle and falls on his face while doing so.
I guess what I'm trying to say is that the people who are hurt in Bed Stuy are probably doing shady business. I don't think they DESERVE it, but it's not like innocents are regularly gunned down. And where I'm at, I haven't really felt uncomfortable. There are some sketchy characters (namely the stoop/bodega people)...but that might just be my innate prejudice against people who clearly aren't working in the middle of the day. I don't feel comfortable with people just staring at me either, but that's just the neighborhood. I don't personally care unless someone bothers me, which they don't. I say hi to some people if they genuinely look nice and are not just staring at the "new black kid who is clearly not from around here."
Do I feel like I'm part of this gentification process? Sometimes. But that's only because people apparently think less of someone who would prefer to have a nice big place in a decent, but not affluent neighborhood as opposed to a shoebox in Manhattan. I don't think I'm gentrifying anything...if I can afford a bigger place, don't blame me. I'm not driving up property value...I'm just a kid, with a job who does not feel uncomfortable around black people. I'd say the same for the whites who live in this area. Lucky for me is that:
1. I am not ashamed of who I am and I feel comfortable around my own people. I don't flaunt jewelry or try and impose myself on anyone. If I'm wearing dress clothes it's because I'm going to work, just like countless other people in the neighborhood.
2. I'm not white. But fundamentally, I don't see the difference between someone in my situation and a white-non-hipster fellow who wants to live where he or she is comfortable.
Ignorance and intolerance should not be acceptable anywhere. By your logic, if I moved to Bensonhurst, I should be mugged and beaten because I'm black... (oh wait...)
It's people with your style of thinking that propagate negative thoughts about integration and growth. -
No name face- I appreciate what you've said. The last paragraph got a little off centered, but aside from that, it was great.
Ok- re-reading what I posted, I can even see where I may be misinterpreted as mistaking race for class. I was trying to keep my posting succinct. I think I excised some important points in the process.
The "yuppies" I refer to are not confined by color. I think "hipster" would have been a better word than "yuppie". And furthermore- I see plenty of young black males from the neighborhood dressing in ways I'm not used to seeing black males dress. One thing I didn't mention is that I ingratiated myself in the skateboard and punk rock culture when I was younger. I see young black men carrying skateboards, wearing tight pants, wearing aviator sunglasses, and for lack of a better word, looking like hipsters. And if that's what they want to do, good for them.
If white people want to move to Bed Stuy, good for them. But I feel like most of the white folks I've seen in Bed Stuy look as if they're trying too hard. I've seen black folks in Bed Stuy that look as if they're trying too hard, too. It's just easier to spot the white cats. My partner said today, as a white dude walked up Nostrand with his Ipod on "Please rob me". We see weakness and vulnerability because we've perfected not showing it. Sometimes this vulnerability is humorous to us. It's sick and sad, but it's true.
I looked at Craigslist before I moved into my apartment in Park Slope, which is where my grandparents, aunts, and uncles lived before they had to sell buildings and jump ship, so to speak, when the neighborhood turned to shit. The rents in Bed Stuy are comparable to, if not exactly the same as the rents here. And I live in the yuppie capital of Brooklyn, I'm ashamed to say. These are my roots, though.
So I sympathize with the Bed Stuy natives who own beautiful brownstones and rent a floor to lily-white, idealistic suburbanites. I sympathize with the natives who rent to black yuppie suburbanites.
I got called to a beautiful brownstone last week and found five ancient Schwinns in the hallway, and as we were carrying the guy out of the house, I said "Let me guess, you rent to yuppies"
This large, black, military family, neighborhood native man said sarcastically "How'd you guess?"
He was resigned.
I've told my lieutenant- Bed Stuy should be a black enclave instead of a black ghetto. It's a beautiful place. It could be a wonderful neighborhood.
And in response to the queries as to whether I'd say "Blacks go home" or whether or not I'd advocate white-on-black violence in Bensonhurst, the answer is unequivocally: Absolutely not.
Bed Stuy is a black neighborhood. There are class differences throughout the neighborhood. No matter where you go, unless you live in the projects, rent is the same as it would be anywhere else in the city. So "yuppies" white or black or asian or pacific islanders cannot hide behind cheap rent for a place with amazing square footage with wood floors and no roaches, cuz I would have known about it before you moved here.
The rents in Bed Stuy are no cheaper than anywhere else. I know this. Bed Stuy is as beautiful as Park Slope, if not, moreso.
And yes- maybe I look at the people I serve as charges that I must nobly protect- but I do look at them as people.
If anyone has any other problems with me- post em. -
So much of your anti-white or anti-hipster or anti-(insert euphemism here) commentary is based strictly the outward appearances of these people. And that's pretty weak, IMO.
Most of your original post was interesting to me as it was based largely on experiences of actually getting to know people. Then you took this violent anti-(insert euphemism here) turn that was based strictly on dress, or using an ipod out in the open, or keeping bikes in the hallway.
Your whole post just ended up being a typical anti-gentrification rant. Which is to say, boring and tired. -
Do people truly believe that the rents in Bed Stuy are the same as in Park Slope?
-
The thing that SevenAdam's post forgets is that New York is all about change. There is no such thing as a "black neighborhood" or a "white neighborhood" in the big picture. This whole city is about the flow of money and resources, and nobody owns the right to anything like a neighborhood here.
Bed Stuy used to be a white neighborhood. I personally hope it becomes a fantastically *diverse* neighborhood. I like that my block in Bed Stuy is increasingly diverse. My street is welcoming to both black and white new folks; takes care of issues like the drug dealers down the street or fast traffic; and is comfortable for everyone who wants a nice, quiet(ish) place to live.
(And as a landlord, I have to say that I laughed so hard at the idea that the rents in PS are comparable to BS that coffee came out my nose!) -
I kind of ignored that part.
Ben wrote: Do people truly believe that the rents in Bed Stuy are the same as in Park Slope?
-
Doesn't seem like anyone is all that concerned about the shooting and killing of a young Fort Greene resident that took place in the Ingersoll Housing Project over on Navy Walk very early on Sunday morning.
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/23/nyregion/23mbrfs-fight.html?_r=1&oref=slogin
Just an observation. -
SevenAdam wrote: I've told my lieutenant- Bed Stuy should be a black enclave instead of a black ghetto.
See, SevenAdam, again I'm not seeing why you need to specify that it should be a "black" enclave as opposed to a "black" ghetto. Why do you specify the RACE of the people living there? Why not simply say "it should be a neighborhood instead of a ghetto"? Why do you continue to call attention to the race of the people who live there? -
Focusing on race and wanting division out of "respect" for difference generally just backfires on the group with the least power.
Black people should want white people streaming into their neighborhoods and vice-versa because black and white people need desperately to become more culturally flexible and more attuned to common goals.
Race is a terrible, destructive distraction from larger problems. -
Focusing on race and wanting division out of "respect" for difference generally just backfires on the group with the least power.
hear hear
Black people should want white people streaming into their neighborhoods and vice-versa because black and white people need desperately to become more culturally flexible and more attuned to common goals.
Race is a terrible, destructive distraction from larger problems. -
SevenAdam,
my question is how exactly are certain white/black people 'trying too hard'? i don't listen to my ipod when i exit the subway because i don't want to get robbed. period. if i did choose to listen to my ipod, would i be trying too hard? i think it's more like 'being stupid', personally.
please clarify this...thanks.
relating to everything else you said, it seems like you believe in separate but equal...which isn't a racist notion, but certainly counterproductive. you're saying you wouldn't praise white on black racism in Bensonhurst is sort of counter to how you feel about white people in a predominately black Bed Stuy, no? can you please explain exactly what you mean with that too? -
Yikes drama.
I sense a lot of tension on this board.
In any case, I am moving to Bed-Stuy and I am sensitive to the existing community as well as thinking through how my move there will complicate things in the context of gentrification. The real estate is pretty hideous, south Stuy is gorgeous but the prices were right up north. Hopefully tensions will decrease, dialogues will increase, and the community will continue to grow in a positive sense. -
I am a native New Yorker, and I recently moved to Bed-Stuy. As a white person who would likely be classified as a "midwestern-born hipster" by SevenAdam, I was concerned about being perceived as a face of gentrification by long-term residents. However, I want to make it clear (as I'm sure many people on this board already recognize) that I haven't met any Bed-Stuy newbies who just decided to live there for some mythical cool factor when they could just as well be living in Park Slope. I'm young, I don't make a lot of money, and the prices in Bed-Stuy are within my budget. Speaking of which, I have no idea what SevenAdam is talking about when he says that the prices are comparable to Park Slope; as someone who was recently apartment-hunting, I can attest that such an idea is pure fantasy.
Furthermore, I'm shocked by the intensity of the generalizations put forth by this post. By being a white person living in a predominantly black neighborhood, am I supposed to dress a certain way to 'blend in,' rather than wearing what I'm used to, since it seems to be setting me up? If so, what would that costume be? I assume it would have to cover up all of my exposed skin, since simply being white seems to mean I'm a yuppie.
Also, the notion that if you dress a certain way, you're "asking for it" is horrifying on a variety of levels, and reminds me of people who attest that women who dress provocatively deserve to be assaulted. I don't care how someone's dressed, if they are minding their own business and simply trying to live, they're not asking for anything different than the person next to them who looks more 'normal.' The way one dresses should not be an invitation to violence or harrassment. Neither should the color of one's skin or one's perceived sexual orientation. I find it deeply disturbing that an individual, especially one in the public service, would promote such an idea.
The idea that there is a "real" Bed-Stuy community and that anyone with white skin is an interloper is completely adverse to what should be going on here. This kind of hostility towards white people specifically would be completely intolerable if the situation were reversed. People who are moving into any neighborhood, whether they are white, black, latino, asian, any race, any combination of races, who are genuinely invested in living in the area, contributing to it, and improving it, are members of a community. The further implication that only black people are welcomed to be served by you as an EMT is unsettling on an entirely separate plane.
I think it's quite sad that you don't consider yourself to have racial prejudices, since you clearly expect black people to be one way and white people to be another. You see black males who are not dressing the way you're "used to." Not to mention that while you'll raise your fist up in solidarity while at work, you run back to Park Slope at night to be amongst people to whom you can "relate." -
[ post removed by moderator. no commercial shilling, thanks ]
-
brooklynleather wrote: Yikes drama.
That's just kind of the nature of the Internet, actually; some people are just more likely to sound off about things from behind a computer, since they have comparative anonymity and "no one" can know it's "really them" who says it. There's actually a web comic that one referred to the phenomenon as "the Internet F*ckwad Theory."
I sense a lot of tension on this board.
It happened before, it'll happen again; it's not as such anything you said, fret not. :-)[/url] -
What is commercial shilling? :?:
Howdy, Stranger!
Categories
- 40K All Categories
- 27.1K Neighborhoods
- 5.1K Crown Heights/Prospect Lefferts Gardens
- 7.1K Prospect Heights
- 2.3K Fort Greene, Clinton Hill, Bed-Stuy
- 8K Park Slope
- 549 Williamsburg, Greenpoint, Bushwick
- 442 Flatbush/Midwood/Ditmas Park
- 657 BoCoCa (Boerum Hill, Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens)
- 151 Red Hook
- 104 Gowanus
- 304 Bay Ridge/Bensonhurst
- 130 Coney Island, Brighton Beach, Sheepshead Bay
- 270 Brooklyn Heights, DUMBO and Downtown
- 598 Windsor Terrace / Kensington
- 673 Greenwood Heights and Sunset Park
- 749 Brooklyn and Beyond
- 6.3K Stuff
- 86 Brooklyn Back When
- 1.2K Brooklyn Pets
- 257 Brooklyn Kids
- 241 Brooklyn Eats
- 51 Brooklyn Booze
- 3.6K The Lounge / Random Stuff
- 611 Brooklyn Politics
- 122 Brooklyn Sports and Fitness
- 111 Brooklyn Photos
- 339 Site Issues
- 8 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- 6.2K Listings
- 1.1K APARTMENTS and REAL ESTATE
- 1.3K Sales Openings Events
- 2.3K The Classifieds







