what is this tree?
When I was walking home from the store, I walked past this tree that had fruit dropping off it. The leaves are a triangular shape and the fruit looks like yellow cherries. I think it's neat, but I have no idea what it is.
I wish I could provide a picture, but the camera part of my phone isn't working.
I wish I could provide a picture, but the camera part of my phone isn't working.
Comments
-
sound like gingko tree:


If you don't spray it, the fruit will smell really bad.... -
The rotten fruit smells like crap. Literally. It can turn whole blocks into wreaking sewers. But the trees are gorgeous.
-
Hate to be a downer about any kind of tree, but...
Yikes, Gingko trees. Just wait until the droppings foul and the smell starts.
Aiiee. A strong, noxious mixture of vomit and fecal matter envelops the block, and all those droppings get mashed down into the pavement from all the foot traffic so it can't just be washed or swept away.
Trees in general? Very nice. Gingkos? Not so nice. What a mess. -
Yea, it does smell like dog crap.
It is the female gingko tree that makes the fruit/seeds.
But you dont know which one you have until decades later:
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9500E0DB1538F932A35753C1A9649C8B63Q & A; Avoiding Ginkgo Fruit
Its really too bad because it really is an absolutely beautiful tree with fantastic leaves.
By C. CLAIBORNE RAY
Published: October 1, 2002
Q. The female ginkgo tree on my street is dropping its smelly fruit on the pavement. Is there no way that the sex of a tree can be determined before it is planted?
A. It is scientifically possible to determine whether a young Ginkgo biloba tree is male or female, but a DNA test would be far too expensive for routine use.
The trees do not reach reproductive age and publicly reveal their sex for two or three decades or more. Nurseries often produce their planting trees using cuttings, to make sure that only males end up on the street, according to an extensive Web site at www.xs4all.nl/kwanten/, maintained by a teacher and ginkgo fan, Cor Kwant of the Netherlands.
The decaying fruit's outer coating is said to smell like rancid butter; the odor comes from butyric acid. The coating also contains an oil called urushiol, which in sensitive people can produce reactions not unlike those to poison ivy and raw cashews, which also contain it. Once its coating is removed by thorough rinsing (using rubber gloves), the nut can be toasted and eaten like any other nut and is a delicacy in Asia.
Ginkgos have an unusual method of reproduction. The sperm, which usually reaches the female trees by being windblown, moves on its own within the ovules found on the female tree. It is not clear whether fertilization of the egg nucleus takes place while the fruit is still on the tree or months after it has fallen. C. CLAIBORNE RAY
So if you want one, it may be possible to break off a branch of a mature, non-fruit-producing male and plant those branches...? I'm not a horticulturist, so I'm not sure if that is completely fool-proof plan..... -
So are stinky girl trees? That is very funny.

-
well, I think you guys are right and it is a ginkgo tree. The only reason why I didn't immediately recognize it was that the fruit that had fallen off didn't have an unpleasant smell. I suppose it hadn't had a chance to rot yet.
But then rotting fruit never smells good.
The one advantage of female trees though is that they soak up the pollen from the male trees, thus reducing allergies in the surrounding area. One theory as to why allergies are so much more pervasive in urban areas is that most cities will plant mostly male trees because they don't want to deal with the mess of female trees with the result that all that excess pollen doesn't have anywhere to go. AHCHOO!!
I never had allergies when I was growing up, even though I lived across the street from a big patch of ragweed (I still think I'm not allergic to it). We had a female maple and a female oak in the front yard and that probably helped keep the pollen under control. -
lilbangladesh wrote:
Gotta call bullshit on this one. What fraction of pollen reaches its target when there are equal numbers of trees? 10e-5? 10e-6?
The one advantage of female trees though is that they soak up the pollen from the male trees, thus reducing allergies in the surrounding area. One theory as to why allergies are so much more pervasive in urban areas is that most cities will plant mostly male trees because they don't want to deal with the mess of female trees with the result that all that excess pollen doesn't have anywhere to go. AHCHOO!! -
god i hate those things. i hate them especially in prospect park. i wish they would rid them all of them!!!
-
I said it was a "theory". Some allergist was trying to come up with a reason why seasonal allergies are so much worse in the inner city than they are in rural areas, and the only thing he could point to was the fact that there is usually such an imbalance of tree sexes in the city.
I mean, if 90% of the trees around you are male, then that is a proportionally greater amount of pollen floating around, no? -
lilbangladesh wrote: ...usually such an imbalance of tree sexes in the city.
Next on Nova: Darren Star presents...
sassy_music.loadSound("cha-cha.mp3",true); -
SevenOneEighty wrote:
amateur hortimiculturaly speaking, you'd have better odds trying to sprout the fruit than with breaking off a branch.
Its really too bad because it really is an absolutely beautiful tree with fantastic leaves.
Ginkgos have an unusual method of reproduction. The sperm, which usually reaches the female trees by being windblown, moves on its own within the ovules found on the female tree. It is not clear whether fertilization of the egg nucleus takes place while the fruit is still on the tree or months after it has fallen. C. CLAIBORNE RAY
So if you want one, it may be possible to break off a branch of a mature, non-fruit-producing male and plant those branches...? I'm not a horticulturist, so I'm not sure if that is completely fool-proof plan..... -
well if you ever get plant hormones you take a cutting of a branch plant it in any material but outside garden soil. within a short time roots will take root.
-
pitu wrote: [quote=SevenOneEighty]So if you want one, it may be possible to break off a branch of a mature, non-fruit-producing male and plant those branches...? I'm not a horticulturist, so I'm not sure if that is completely fool-proof plan.....
amateur hortimiculturaly speaking, you'd have better odds trying to sprout the fruit than with breaking off a branch.
Well, except that didn't I read above that the male is non fruit producing, making this somewhat difficult?
-
daver wrote: [quote=pitu][quote=SevenOneEighty]So if you want one, it may be possible to break off a branch of a mature, non-fruit-producing male and plant those branches...? I'm not a horticulturist, so I'm not sure if that is completely fool-proof plan.....
amateur hortimiculturaly speaking, you'd have better odds trying to sprout the fruit than with breaking off a branch.
Well, except that didn't I read above that the male is non fruit producing, making this somewhat difficult?
You could use the fruit and take your chances.
But it also seems like I was not that far off anyway...some quick web research, below:
One of the reasons some gingkos are considered endangered is because of the grafting of male 'cultivars' for growth...apparently this is a common practice because of the preference for non-fruit bearing male trees:
http://hcs.osu.edu/pocketgardener/source/description/gi_iloba.htmlpropagated primarily by cuttings from male cultivars grafted onto seedling rootstock, but also propagated by seed (where the gender of the offspring is often not visually determined for at least twenty years)
..I was just guessing.
Also, remember, it could take decades to determine the sex of the tree....it may be too late then. -
SevenOneEighty wrote: [quote=daver][quote=pitu][quote=SevenOneEighty]So if you want one, it may be possible to break off a branch of a mature, non-fruit-producing male and plant those branches...? I'm not a horticulturist, so I'm not sure if that is completely fool-proof plan.....
amateur hortimiculturaly speaking, you'd have better odds trying to sprout the fruit than with breaking off a branch.
Well, except that didn't I read above that the male is non fruit producing, making this somewhat difficult?
You could use the fruit and take your chances.
But it also seems like I was not that far off anyway...some quick web research, below:
One of the reasons some gingkos are considered endangered is because of the grafting of male 'cultivars' for growth...apparently this is a common practice because of the preference for non-fruit bearing male trees:
http://hcs.osu.edu/pocketgardener/source/description/gi_iloba.htmlpropagated primarily by cuttings from male cultivars grafted onto seedling rootstock, but also propagated by seed (where the gender of the offspring is often not visually determined for at least twenty years)
..I was just guessing.
Also, remember, it could take decades to determine the sex of the tree....it may be too late then.
Grafting on root stock is different from breaking off a branch and sticking it in the ground. The city must buy grafted male trees tho, since they don't plant the female ginkos anymore because of the mess and stink.
This will be a loss to the Chinese community -- there's ladies in my nabe that gather up the fruit as soon as it falls, for the ginko nuts within.
I don't think the root hormone thing works for big ol' tree limbs. I do that with tender plants, not woody stuff.
Do you know something I don't, armchair? -
pitu wrote: [quote=SevenOneEighty][quote=daver][quote=pitu][quote=SevenOneEighty]So if you want one, it may be possible to break off a branch of a mature, non-fruit-producing male and plant those branches...? I'm not a horticulturist, so I'm not sure if that is completely fool-proof plan.....
amateur hortimiculturaly speaking, you'd have better odds trying to sprout the fruit than with breaking off a branch.
Well, except that didn't I read above that the male is non fruit producing, making this somewhat difficult?
You could use the fruit and take your chances.
But it also seems like I was not that far off anyway...some quick web research, below:
One of the reasons some gingkos are considered endangered is because of the grafting of male 'cultivars' for growth...apparently this is a common practice because of the preference for non-fruit bearing male trees:
http://hcs.osu.edu/pocketgardener/source/description/gi_iloba.htmlpropagated primarily by cuttings from male cultivars grafted onto seedling rootstock, but also propagated by seed (where the gender of the offspring is often not visually determined for at least twenty years)
..I was just guessing.
Also, remember, it could take decades to determine the sex of the tree....it may be too late then.
Grafting on root stock is different from breaking off a branch and sticking it in the ground. The city must buy grafted male trees tho, since they don't plant the female ginkos anymore because of the mess and stink.
This will be a loss to the Chinese community -- there's ladies in my nabe that gather up the fruit as soon as it falls, for the ginko nuts within.
I don't think the root hormone thing works for big ol' tree limbs. I do that with tender plants, not woody stuff.
Do you know something I don't, armchair?
Um, I know....
I was just pulling from my bonsai experience - I have started a few from branches from full grown trees...again, it was just a guess. I was approaching it more from a "concept" of selecting 'stock' from a male tree as a starting point... -
Aah the ginkgo tree or I should say the female ginkgo tree. Gorgeous when not dropping her putrid smelling fruit. I've read that this is the oldest living tree on earth, pre-dating the ice age.
Do not touch the flesh and skin as they are toxic as is the fluid. The Asian community uses the nuts inside mostly for medicinal purposes.
Another interesting tidbit: In Washington State, there is a petrified gingko tree forest estimated to be 15 million years old. -
I picked up the fruit and squished it. Nothing happened.
While it may not be safe to eat, I call bullshit on the claimed toxicity. I mean, how would gingko nuts be harvested if you couldn't touch the berries? -
lilbangladesh wrote: I picked up the fruit and squished it. Nothing happened.
I call trueshit, and raise you the possibility that testing toxicity by trying it is perhaps not the best method of finding out
While it may not be safe to eat, I call bullshit on the claimed toxicity.
. A websearch reveals multiple citations of said toxicity, along with multiple dermatitis outbreaks (mostly among children) attributed to the same. I offer two of each.
http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1600-0536.1988.tb02928.x
http://pubs.caes.uga.edu/caespubs/horticulture/H-00-056.pdf
http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1600-0536.1985.tb01138.x
http://www.yardener.com/AvoidingPoisonousPlants.html -
Here's an abstract from a case report of one kid that got poisoned:
Hasegawa S, Oda Y, Ichiyama T, Hori Y, Furukawa S. Ginkgo nut intoxication in a 2-year-old male. Pediatr Neurol 2006 Oct;35(4):275-6.
Department of Allergy, Yamaguchi University, School of Medicine, and Department of Hospital Pharmacy, Niigata City General Hospital, Japan.
This report describes a case of ginkgo nut intoxication in a 2-year-old male. The patient presented with vomiting and afebrile convulsion 4 hours after eating a large number of roasted gingko nuts. There was a large volume of ginkgo nuts in his vomited matter, and on admission the concentrations of 4-O-methoxypyridoxine in his serum and urine were elevated. The patient was diagnosed as having ginkgo nut intoxication, and diazepam and pyridoxal phosphate were administered intravenously. After the treatment, his symptoms were resolved. The neurotoxicity of ginkgo nuts should be recognized by pediatricians and parents who have infants.
PMID: 16996402 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
Here's another:
Miwa H, Iijima M, Tanaka S, Mizuno Y. Generalized convulsions after consuming a large amount of gingko nuts. Epilepsia 2001 Feb;42(2):280-1.
Departments of Neurology, Juntendo University Urayasu Hospital, Chiba, Japan. [email protected]
We report a 36-year-old woman, without any past or family histories of epilepsy, who presented frequent vomiting and generalized convulsions. About 4 h before the convulsion, she had consumed approximately 70-80 gingko nuts, seeds of Gingko biloba, in an attempt to improve her health. It is important to know that convulsion may be induced if a large amount of gingko nuts is consumed. The neurotoxicity of gingko nuts, particularly their convulsion-inducing effect, should be recognized.
PMID: 11240603 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE] -
lilbangladesh wrote: I picked up the fruit and squished it. Nothing happened. ...I call bullshit...
Your methodology leaves something to be desired. -
pitu wrote:
i was being lazy. if you want to clone tree's do it with leafs
I don't think the root hormone thing works for big ol' tree limbs. I do that with tender plants, not woody stuff.
Do you know something I don't, armchair?
. extra writing sucks for me hehe.
note: i haven't done any type of plant cloning in over a decade with hormones
. only cloning i done with them is just plan cut roots apart and hope for the best hehe. cheaper super failure is about more than half. -
well, duh. Those people ATE the stuff. Generally, eating stuff off trees without knowing what they are is a bad idea. Of COURSE there was neurotoxicity.
I just dispute that you could poison yourself just by touching the berries. Now maybe if you rolled around naked in a pile of them you could give yourself something nasty, but I'm not about to do that. -
lilbangladesh wrote: I just dispute that you could poison yourself just by touching the berries. Now maybe if you rolled around naked in a pile of them you could give yourself something nasty, but I'm not about to do that.
I posted two links to documented dermatitis outbreaks caused by kids playing with them, not eating them, FYI... -
Yeah, but I couldn't read the damn articles without paying for them.
I love academic links, I really do. I used them all the time for work, but have pity for us broke folks! -
you can get the jist by reading the abstracts, which are free. as were 2 of the 4 links daver put up. or you could just trust him.
just because you didn't have a problem, doesn't mean it doesn't happen. i'm skin-allergic to mango skin. so are lots of other people, though not everyone. -
Ok, that makes sense.
I'm like allergic to EVERYTHING, so it makes a weird sort of sense that I would be totally non-reactive to gingko.
I live in OppositeLand! Oh yes... -
according to some class at the BBG, nyc actually banned ginko trees from the city in the 70s(?) but still they prevail.
also, ginko nuts are toxic -- but they are only situational toxicants. they can be used medicinally: usually short term & for people with disease patterns that match the function of the ginko nut. they are toxic in a similar way that too much alcohol can be toxic to the body.
also, ginko nuts harvested in nyc seem suspect --- who knows what those trees have absorbed from the ground or from insecticides are dropped on us in the city -- yuck. -
Well, good lord, I don't think anyone was advocating eating the things!
Celestial Seasonings put out a tea with gingko in it. Gingko is supposed to help improve the memory.
Of course, too much of anything is toxic. People have died from drinking too much water or water toxicity. (Didn't someone die after a water drinking contest on the Howard Stern show?) -
No.
Howdy, Stranger!
Categories
- 40K All Categories
- 27.1K Neighborhoods
- 5.1K Crown Heights/Prospect Lefferts Gardens
- 7.1K Prospect Heights
- 2.3K Fort Greene, Clinton Hill, Bed-Stuy
- 8K Park Slope
- 549 Williamsburg, Greenpoint, Bushwick
- 442 Flatbush/Midwood/Ditmas Park
- 657 BoCoCa (Boerum Hill, Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens)
- 151 Red Hook
- 104 Gowanus
- 304 Bay Ridge/Bensonhurst
- 130 Coney Island, Brighton Beach, Sheepshead Bay
- 270 Brooklyn Heights, DUMBO and Downtown
- 598 Windsor Terrace / Kensington
- 673 Greenwood Heights and Sunset Park
- 749 Brooklyn and Beyond
- 6.3K Stuff
- 86 Brooklyn Back When
- 1.2K Brooklyn Pets
- 257 Brooklyn Kids
- 241 Brooklyn Eats
- 51 Brooklyn Booze
- 3.6K The Lounge / Random Stuff
- 611 Brooklyn Politics
- 122 Brooklyn Sports and Fitness
- 111 Brooklyn Photos
- 339 Site Issues
- 8 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- 6.2K Listings
- 1.1K APARTMENTS and REAL ESTATE
- 1.3K Sales Openings Events
- 2.3K The Classifieds










