Holiday Trees In The Slope

LongTimeSloper wrote: so, tell me oh wise Carnivore, just what holiday are secular people who go out and buy trees and then exchange gifts on December 25th celebrating? did you come up with a new holiday just to fit your ideals?

And, I am still wondering what you call those colorful eggs that people decorate in the spring.

They are celebrating the holiday season, which includes every holiday during that time. And some people just like the smell of an evergreen tree and exchanging presents.

And the eggs that Christians decorate for Easter are Easter eggs.

And what should we now call the planets? See, I don't worship the Greek gods, and I'm offended that it's suggested we call them Mars, Venus, Mercury, etc.

Carnivore wrote: [quote=LongTimeSloper]so, tell me oh wise Carnivore, just what holiday are secular people who go out and buy trees and then exchange gifts on December 25th celebrating? did you come up with a new holiday just to fit your ideals?

And, I am still wondering what you call those colorful eggs that people decorate in the spring.

They are celebrating the holiday season, which includes every holiday during that time. And some people just like the smell of an evergreen tree and exchanging presents.

And the eggs that Christians decorate for Easter are Easter eggs.

You are a riot, you really are!

anthonycm wrote: And what should we now call the planets? See, I don't worship the Greek gods, and I'm offended that it's suggested we call them Mars, Venus, Mercury, etc.

Straw man argument. I'm not suggesting we need to change the name of Corpus Christi, or any of the San cities in the West and South. I'm just saying that you can't tell people what to call something that they put in their own home for their own reasons.

Carnivore wrote: [quote=hitokiri]First off, your soap box is brittle and will break. I suggest you get off of it for now.

You're the one who was so outraged that someone would dare to not mention Christmas when inquiring about a holiday tree

hitokiri wrote: Second of all, you are CORRECT. It is not a Christmas Tree if the person is not celebrating christmas

Exactly. And just because they buy it in December doesn't mean they're celebrating your holiday.
Decorating trees has nothing to do with the birth of Christ.

Would you be outraged if I refused to call you a human?

Ok, they used the name Holiday Tree... but you cant have a holiday without a name. WHICH holiday are they getting a tree for? Christmas. Hense it's a Christmas tree.

Have you ever gotten a "holiday tree" for Memorial Day or the 4th of July?

it's as simple as this.
If it looks like a duck and walks like a duck...

hitokiri wrote: Would you be outraged if I refused to call you a human?

it's as simple as this.
If it looks like a duck and walks like a duck...

Why is it so complicated for you that when someone has a tree and doesn't celebrate Christmas, it's not a Christmas tree?

What do you think the Pope (not to imply that all Christians are Catholic, but just as an example) would say if you asked him what it means to "celebrate Christmas"? Do you think he would say that someone who buys a tree and puts tinsel on it is celebrating Christmas? I don't think so.

Carnivore,

If people are free to call the tree whatever they want, as I believe you claimed, then non-Christians are free to call the tree a Christmas tree. Just because they call something by it's name doesn't mean they're falling for the particular dogma behind that name.

Again, I'm not Jewish, but even if menorahs get so popular every household in the world has one, I'm calling it a menorah because, well, that's what it's called.

Pretty sure you don't speak for all the Jews.

anthonycm wrote: Pretty sure you don't speak for all the Jews.

No, I don't. But the point remains clear.

Carnivore wrote: [quote=hitokiri]Would you be outraged if I refused to call you a human?

it's as simple as this.
If it looks like a duck and walks like a duck...

Why is it so complicated for you that when someone has a tree and doesn't celebrate Christmas, it's not a Christmas tree?

What do you think the Pope (not to imply that all Christians are Catholic, but just as an example) would say if you asked him what it means to "celebrate Christmas"? Do you think he would say that someone who buys a tree and puts tinsel on it is celebrating Christmas? I don't think so.

Dont try to make a point by severely cutting up a quote and making it sound like I am closed minded without an actual point.

Let me help remind you of the full post

"Would you be outraged if I refused to call you a human?

Ok, they used the name Holiday Tree... but you cant have a holiday without a name. WHICH holiday are they getting a tree for? Christmas. Hense it's a Christmas tree.

Have you ever gotten a "holiday tree" for Memorial Day or the 4th of July?

it's as simple as this.
If it looks like a duck and walks like a duck..."

The bold part is the MAIN point that I would like you to work with.
Coincidentally it is the part that you left out and shot at me saying why cant I cant understand your reasoning.

That bold part IS the reason why i dont understand your reasoning.

Mamacita wrote: [quote=Carnivore][quote=anthonycm]Pretty sure you don't speak for all the Jews.

No, I don't. But the point remains clear.

But who will speak for the Druish?

The schwartz. End of story! ;p

hitokiri wrote: [quote=Carnivore][quote=hitokiri]Would you be outraged if I refused to call you a human?

it's as simple as this.
If it looks like a duck and walks like a duck...

Why is it so complicated for you that when someone has a tree and doesn't celebrate Christmas, it's not a Christmas tree?

What do you think the Pope (not to imply that all Christians are Catholic, but just as an example) would say if you asked him what it means to "celebrate Christmas"? Do you think he would say that someone who buys a tree and puts tinsel on it is celebrating Christmas? I don't think so.

Dont try to make a point by severely cutting up a quote and making it sound like I am closed minded without an actual point.

Let me help remind you of the full post

"Would you be outraged if I refused to call you a human?

Ok, they used the name Holiday Tree... but you cant have a holiday without a name. WHICH holiday are they getting a tree for? Christmas. Hense it's a Christmas tree.

Have you ever gotten a "holiday tree" for Memorial Day or the 4th of July?

it's as simple as this.
If it looks like a duck and walks like a duck..."

The bold part is the MAIN point that I would like you to work with.
Coincidentally it is the part that you left out and shot at me saying "why I cant understand"

That bold part IS the reason why "i dont understand"

I didn't cut up your quote. I quoted you directly, and then you went back and edited what you said afterward.

And to address your point, I've already answered that question when LongTimeSloper asked it.

Carnivore wrote: [quote=LongTimeSloper]so, tell me oh wise Carnivore, just what holiday are secular people who go out and buy trees and then exchange gifts on December 25th celebrating? did you come up with a new holiday just to fit your ideals?

They are celebrating the holiday season, which includes every holiday during that time. And some people just like the smell of an evergreen tree and exchanging presents.

my edit was 11:17

your post was 11:21


but it was an edit, so its possible it happened. I'll give the benefit of the doubt

Anastasia Beaverhausen wrote: Carn - you're going to have to stand behind me at the Festivus party while I use Harriette to beat people back who want to do you harm.

Surely no one will want to do me harm based on a simple debate!

But thanks for the offer.

I just want an excuse to bring my pretty pink tree with me. Kick Carny's ass everyone!